Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Name me one unattractive hero. Heroes always have had dashing looks. James Bond, Magnum, MacGyver. They're always cool.
The core attraction at first were the MacGyverisms, no doubt. I'm sure the first season has the most MacGyverisms of all seasons. Later I think it was more because RDA played the role and because of the more domestic problems. Kids that needed help, environmental issues and endangered species.
Explain ugly.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 2
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
QUOTE
Explain ugly.
Well, beauty...and ugly...is in the eye of the beholder!
I seriously doubt they would have cast the show with someone who didn't fit the all-American-cute-guy bill...but I'm also sure that there's got to be some girl out there in this huge wide world who DOESN'T think RDA is attractive. Right? Am I crazy? It's not me...I do think he's pretty darn cute, but not the cutest guy in the world...because I married that guy.
I never started watching MacGyver because of RDA. I didn't even know who he was!!!! As Nymphy has been so fond of poking fun at me for...I'd never seen him in anything else but MacGyver until I finally saw SG-1 for the first time last year!
I probably started watching it because it was action and adventure, which I loved. When I saw that MacGyver used his brains instead of weapons and how cool it was he could come up with solutions to a problem just by using what's around him...I was hooked! And he was an ordinary guy...he didn't rely on unbelievable gadgets or superpowers and he wasn't invincible. Those were all the things the made me a fan. I think I would have watched it no matter who was cast, as long as the actor fit the role! After all these years, I can't imagine another actor playing MacGyver...but I remember Rock saying a long time ago that if they made a MacGyver movie without RDA starring, he'd still go see it cuz it's MacGyver. I think I would, too. Thinking about that...you know who I think might be "acceptable" in the role? Nicholas Cage, maybe. After National Treasure I can almost picture that.
"It's amazing what one can do when one doesn't know what one can't do." Garfield the Cat
"Another day, a whole 'nother set of fresh possibilities. I'm a sucker for mornings." MacGyver
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Richard Gere is more like it. He had something of RDA in the early 90's. However Nicolas Cage wouldn't be a bad choice either.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Bitter Harvest
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
QUOTE (Rockatteer @ Nov 29 2006, 05:46 AM)
If MacGyver was ugly, would the show still have the fans and appeal?
What was the core attraction of MacGyver? Was it the fact that RDA played the part? Was it the MacGyverisms, or something else?
I just found this question in one of my email alerts and thought I’d through it out to see what the rest of you thought.
By my definition, 'ugly' transcends mere physical qualities. Someone who doesn't mean my physical description of 'handsome' or 'beautiful' can still be extremely attractive.
As MacGyver, I don't find RDA particularly physically attractive. The mullet and sloppy (and usually ugly) clothes MacGyver sports do zip for me. But I still find MacGyver to be an incredibly attractive man because of his 100W smile and his personality. O'Neill/RDA today is definitely closer to my definition of a 'handsome' man (love that close-crop silver hair), but I don't find O'Neill particularly attractive because I can't stand him (as for RDA... well, I finally find him handsome inside and out! ).
I can't speak for anyone else, but I guess that means my answer to your question is 'yes, I would have found MacGyver appealing even if his features weren't as smooth and easy on the eyes' and 'my core attraction to the character was his personality.'
Mac
"John Sheppard (writer) sent Richard Dean Anderson to Atlantis on MacGyver and Richard Dean Anderson sent John Sheppard (character) to Atlantis on Stargate. My fandoms are getting to be confusing."
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
QUOTE Richard Gere is more like it. He had something of RDA in the early 90's.
Have you noticed, MG, that the 90s are over? I don't see it now.
Unfortunately they are. But I like the 90's so much. Just like the 80's. I just recalled Gere also having a sort of a mullet during those days.
QUOTE
how about Johnny Depp as MacGyver?
Considering his acting abilities... he doesn't act, he becomes. But I don't think he's tall enough. But that shouldn't make a problem.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Rock The Cradle (today)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Hmmm... good question. Just reading the title of the topic, my first thought was "...they would have cast someone pretty to play him."
If the guy was "ugly" to the point of distraction, the show probably wouldn't have done as well, but like has been said, it's up to the watcher what's tolerable and what's not.
Someone said Nicholas Cage. See that I wouldn't be able to wrap my head around. Just don't like him... don't know why.
~ MacNymph ~
Sometimes the uncontrollable urge to mess with people outweighs the millstone of humility.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE (MacNymph @ Nov 29 2006, 06:04 PM)
QUOTE (MacGyverGod @ Nov 30 2006, 03:54 AM)
QUOTE
how about Johnny Depp as MacGyver?
Considering his acting abilities... he doesn't act, he becomes. But I don't think he's tall enough. But that shouldn't make a problem.
"but I don't think he's tall enough"
"But I don't think his tall enough"
QUOTE
Someone said Nicholas Cage. See that I wouldn't be able to wrap my head around. Just don't like him... don't know why.
What do you mean? Becareful I'm a Cage-fan.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Rock The Cradle (today)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE (MacGyverGod @ Nov 30 2006, 06:10 AM)
QUOTE
Someone said Nicholas Cage. See that I wouldn't be able to wrap my head around. Just don't like him... don't know why.
What do you mean? Becareful I'm a Cage-fan.
I can say it again if you like. Just don't like him... don't know why. I do know I don't find him attractive and I don't think he's a particularly good actor. That's not to say there haven't been movies he was in that I liked... National Treasure, Face Off and Matchstick Men. But I don't think I'd watch a television show if he was the main attraction.
And tempting the fates of cheesing others off... don't like Russel Crowe either.
~ MacNymph ~
Sometimes the uncontrollable urge to mess with people outweighs the millstone of humility.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE (MacNymph @ Nov 29 2006, 07:22 PM)
QUOTE (MacGyverGod @ Nov 30 2006, 06:10 AM)
QUOTE
Someone said Nicholas Cage. See that I wouldn't be able to wrap my head around. Just don't like him... don't know why.
What do you mean? Becareful I'm a Cage-fan.
I can say it again if you like. Just don't like him... don't know why. I do know I don't find him attractive and I don't think he's a particularly good actor. That's not to say there haven't been movies he was in that I liked... National Treasure, Face Off and Matchstick Men. But I don't think I'd watch a television show if he was the main attraction.
Is that the reason? Cage is not a TV-actor. He's lucky that Francis Ford Coppola is his uncle.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Bitter Harvest
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
QUOTE (Rockatteer @ Nov 29 2006, 03:55 PM)
maybe the question should have been "If MacGyver was played by someoen without the apparent sex appeal of RDA."
Maybe some unknown average joe-nobody.
RDA was pretty much a nobody when he started on MacGyver.... He has a questionable fashion sense and had to fish out his eyeglasses for his audition, so he must have looked like a geek. I doubt that his 'sex appeal' was the first thing the casting director noticed....
Mac
"John Sheppard (writer) sent Richard Dean Anderson to Atlantis on MacGyver and Richard Dean Anderson sent John Sheppard (character) to Atlantis on Stargate. My fandoms are getting to be confusing."
Favorites
Season: season 2
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
QUOTE
RDA was pretty much a nobody when he started on MacGyver
Not really. He'd already done time on General Hospital which was one of the most popular soaps of the time. For me he was unknown, tho...I'd never watched GH.
In answer to Rock's new version of the question...Yeah...if the show was the same and the actor was good at the role, then I wouldn't care if the guy was well known or not. I'd've still watched it. Well, I guess I did...seeing's how I didn't know who RDA was at the time.
"It's amazing what one can do when one doesn't know what one can't do." Garfield the Cat
"Another day, a whole 'nother set of fresh possibilities. I'm a sucker for mornings." MacGyver
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Bitter Harvest
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
QUOTE (Rockatteer @ Nov 29 2006, 04:32 PM)
QUOTE (Mac)
RDA was pretty much a nobody when he started on MacGyver.
From what I understand he already had a loyal following of (mosly female) fans as Dr. Jeff Webber on General Hospital well before MacGyver.
Funny, I was just discussing this very topic with a colleague a couple of hours ago.
Primetime and daytime tv have different audiences, so it's not certain that someone who would have watched him during the soap would have transferred over a completely different style of show in the evening.
Interesting enough, like me my colleague tried to get into Stargate because of she loved RDA on Mac and... gave up since she can't stand O'Neill either. *shakes head*
Mac
"John Sheppard (writer) sent Richard Dean Anderson to Atlantis on MacGyver and Richard Dean Anderson sent John Sheppard (character) to Atlantis on Stargate. My fandoms are getting to be confusing."
well that doesn't change the fact that he was a known actor when he got cast as MacGyver.
QUOTE (Mac)
Primetime and daytime tv have different audiences, so it's not certain that someone who would have watched him during the soap would have transferred over a completely different style of show in the evening.
Sadly, from what I’ve read on the rdanderson web site, a lot of the female fans seem to be completely obsessed and would watch anything he’s in.. Simply because he’s in it.
I think this kind of obsession is one of the reasons he doesn’t do a lot of public appearances.. Just too many compulsively obsessed fans for him to deal with.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
Sadly, from what I’ve read on the rdanderson web site, a lot of the female fans seem to be completely obsessed and would watch anything he’s in.. Simply because he’s in it.
Isn't that with everyone, or isn't that the idea? But in our cases starlets like Jessica Alba, Devon Aoki, Elisha Cuthbert and Eliza Dushku. Right now things are a bit poor on that for me but I no longer care.
Of course also with male actors. Like I said I'm a fan of Nicholas Cage; National Treasure, 8 MM, Con Air and Windtalkers. Also Bruce Willis, Will Smith, Mel Gibson Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger belongs to that.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
No I don’t mean just huge fans of an actor.. I’m talking borderline stalkers. Some of these fans have very unhealthy obsessive fantasies about RDA. And I can understand how that would scare the crap out of him at public appearances.
Posts: 1,889
Joined: 11 Jan 2006
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned:
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Passages
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
I've given this a lot of thought, because I often hold debates within myself about what kind of man attracts me. Sometimes, I admit, I'm very shallow and go for pure looks; but there's a part of me that finds intelligence, wit, and talent attractive as well. So, to answer Rock's question...
If MacGyver had looked like your Average Joe Mr. Wizard nerd from Cal Tech, it might have taken me a little longer to warm up to the character because of his "ordinariness." It would be like watching a regular scientist in a lab or something. On the other hand, science shows appeal to me, and I would probably eventually be hooked because I would be learning something. If the guy also had a sense of humor, that would help, too. I watch Mythbusters now because they do some very MacGyver-like things. Do they look like RDA? No, not at all--in fact, they're pretty average looking. But that doesn't stop me from watching the show because they manage to make it pretty entertaining with humor and everything.
So, I guess it really depends on the person playing the character. If they had cast an ordinary looking guy, but he still had some form of charisma other than looks, I still would have watched it the way I watch Mythbusters and sometimes Monk now (the Obsessive-Compulsive detective).
"If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer."
Thank you! I have been creeped out. I just got a picture of Mac looking like Depp's Willy Wonka. *Shutters* IT'S NOT FUNNY. I won't be able to sleep tonight.
This post has been edited by Testgate on 29 March 2007 - 10:20 AM
Posts: 2,949
Joined: 11 Nov 2006
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Some people do cross the line into unhealthy obsessions with celebrities. Stalkers are not only annoying, then can be extremely unstable and dangerous. Stalkers worm their way into someone's life and slowly overtake that life. A stalker takes away your power, robs you of your ability to move about the daily business of living. A stalker takes away a person's feelings of safety and security. A stalker turns a person from a secure self confident individual into a fearful shadow of their former self, always living in the shadows and constantly looking over their shoulders, wondering where the stalker will appear next. A stalker interferes with a person's friends and family, harassing them as well as the object of the obsession.
Stalkers turn people into objects to be possessed. Stalkers make people crazy with their actions and unreasonable attachments. Celebrities are not the only people who are targeted by stalkers. Anyone can be the target of a stalker.
I can understand why some celebrities avoid public appearances. Overly adoring fans can make them feel very uncomfortable, even if they don't fear for their safety. I have run into celebrities on the street (I usually go to Park City during the Sundance Film Festival) and I don't recognize them. I nearly stepped on Ashton Kutcher a couple of years ago and I didn't even recognize him. I think most celebrities would like people to enjoy and even admire their work while realizing that the actor and the character are two distinct entities.
As far as the character of MacGyver being unattractive--since when has an American TV hero ever been considered ugly? I think it is one of those unwritten rules that the hero is always attractive, at least physically.
RDA is a handsome man. I found him attractive as MacGyver physically and as a person. I was attracted to the activism that the character displayed as I had many of the same issues on my agenda at the time.
I also like RDA as Jack O'Neill. Yes he is a snarky jerk and his solution to every problem is get a bigger gun. What I find attractive is again the physical, but I also appreceiate RDA's talent to portray this character who is so different from the character most people identify him with. If I ever get the chance, I would love to meet him and talk soltuions to the environmental problems confronting our world today. Who knows, maybe some day........
As for an actor to play the role of MacGyver, should the powers that be decide to film another series or movie, I think I would have to vote for Orlando Bloom. He has that same intensity in his eyes that RDA brought to MacGyver.
Imagination is more important than knowledge. Albert Einstein
The stuff is already here, I just find a different way to use it. MacGyver
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
As for an actor to play the role of MacGyver, should the powers that be decide to film another series or movie, I think I would have to vote for Orlando Bloom. He has that same intensity in his eyes that RDA brought to MacGyver.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:Jack in the Box (...possibly!)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
MacGyverGod! You made the post all squiffy! tsk-tsk!
MacGyver being cute is only part of his charms. It might encourages some to keep watching but if the story lines were bad I'm sure that wouldn't be enough to keep peoples interest. I like that he's good looking and admit a "few" daydreams about him but thats not all that MacGyver is. I think I'd watch MacGyver if he wasn't so good looking because its a clever show with so much more than a pretty face! I like to read books and the fact I don't have a gorgeous looking man to watch doesn't take away my enjoyment for a good story. Actually when they make film of a book I really enjoyed and stick in a handsome actor as the lead without being true to the book it feels wrong!
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)