Which knife is best?
  Reply to this topic Start new topic Start Poll
Track this topic | Email this topic | Print this topic
macgyverman
Posted: 2 July 2007 - 12:17 PM                                    
Quote Post


Challengers Volunteer
*

Posts: 19
Joined: 1 Jul 2007
Gender:  Male
Country: United States
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



Hello everyone! I have a question. I am looking at the SAK's at MacGyver Gear, and I'm really confused! I know that it depends on the specific use, but in your personal opinion, which knife is best? I would like to buy one, but the choices are almost endless! I really have no ideas, and would love to hear from everyone on which one they think is best. I have looked at just about all of them, from the Tinker to the Champ. Thanks for all of the help!

Dan



??? sak.gif ???



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Amy
Posted: 2 July 2007 - 01:41 PM                                    
Quote Post


DXS Agent
*****

Posts: 643
Joined: 4 Apr 2005
Gender:  Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Champ

Favorites
Season: season 2
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



smile.gif I think mine's a way old version of a Champ or superchamp or some such. And honestly, cool as it is, it's got way more stuff than I actually ever use! But i found it for $15 in a resale shop, so I'm not complaining! smile.gif Like you said, it really does depend on what you would use, but my ideal would be

small and large knife blade
flat and philips screw driver
that little mini screwdriver, which then of course requires the corkscrew
scissors
tweezers
file of some kind
reamer thingie madoo...lol, I'm sure I never used it for it's intent, but I like that it's pointy and sharp...

Probly some things I can't think of at the moment, but those are my basics. wink.gif



"It's amazing what one can do when one doesn't know what one can't do." Garfield the Cat

"Another day, a whole 'nother set of fresh possibilities. I'm a sucker for mornings." MacGyver

 
PM                                                                     
Top
MacGyverOnline
Posted: 2 July 2007 - 01:45 PM                                    
Quote Post


Administrator
*********

Posts: 9,373
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:   ---
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: ---
Jacket:  ---
House:  ---



Hi Macgyverman,

My advice would be to buy either the tinker (which is the one we see MacGyver use most often in the show) or the Spartan.

The tinker and spartan are very similar, with the tinker having a phillips screwdriver instead of the corkscrew blade, apart from that, they are the same.

They are both a good size to fit in your pocket and have a useful range of tools to ensure an almost daily use.





Join the MacGyver Online Network

Facebook ~ X ~ Instagram

 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Jesse
Posted: 2 July 2007 - 02:13 PM                                    
Quote Post


Challengers Volunteer
*

Posts: 20
Joined: 8 Jun 2007
Gender:  Male
Country: U.S.
SAK owned: Fieldmaster

Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:The Gauntlet
Vehicle: Truck
Jacket:  Black leather
House:  House boat



Well, for my 2 cents, I'm kinda partial to my Fieldmaster... it's not really one to keep in a pocket though, I bought a leather belt case for it, it's pretty big but I freakin love it. 2 blades, phillips and flat, saw, scissors etc...

Never leave home without it :-)

Jesse



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Tygr
Posted: 2 July 2007 - 02:43 PM                                    
Quote Post


DXS Operative
****

Posts: 314
Joined: 9 Apr 2007
Gender:  Male
Country: United States
SAK owned: Super Tinker

Favorites
Season: season 2
Episode:Easy Target
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  Loft



QUOTE (Jesse @ 2 July 2007 - 02:42 PM)
Well, for my 2 cents, I'm kinda partial to my Fieldmaster... it's not really one to keep in a pocket though, I bought a leather belt case for it, it's pretty big but I freakin love it. 2 blades, phillips and flat, saw, scissors etc...

The Fieldmaster is almost identical to my biggest knife, which is a Super Tinker. If you would ever possibly need the saw, I'd go with the Fieldmaster. If you wouldn't ever need the saw, I'd go with the Super Tinker.

Then again the Explorer Plus looks AWESOME! biggrin.gif drool.gif



'Tis unwise to wake the Tygr.

"Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me." - Psalms 23:4

 
PMUsers Website                                                                     
Top
Kate Mackay
Posted: 3 July 2007 - 08:35 AM                                    
Quote Post


Trouble shooter
**

Posts: 82
Joined: 26 Aug 2005
Gender:  Female
Country:
SAK owned: Camper Red

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Leather Biker
House:  House boat



I think I mentioned it in my profile. But anyway, I will tell you the knife I have is the " Camper Red Victorinox " It has the big and small ( and very sharp ) knives, the cork screw, the thing for little nails and bolts, and the awl, something that looks like a tooth-pick ( it's white and on the end ) and a grey one on the other end. Something that looks like the Swiss Army Knife could be used as a key-chain. Sorry I don't sound so knowledgable about what it has but I think it is just about the best one . I WAS gonna get the one that has the scissors, and the nail filer. But later, as now I am saving up to move out .
I hope this helps.
Sincerely,
Kate Mackay



 
PM                                                                     
Top
macgyverman
Posted: 3 July 2007 - 12:02 PM                                    
Quote Post


Challengers Volunteer
*

Posts: 19
Joined: 1 Jul 2007
Gender:  Male
Country: United States
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



Thanks for the information everyone! This may be a dumb question, but could anyone tell me the difference between the Tinker and the Super Tinker? Right now, I'm leaning toward the Tinker, but thought that I would ask what anyone thought of the Super Tinker. I guess what I mean is, what extra does the Super Tinker have that the Tinker does not have? Thanks for any information.



 
PM                                                                     
Top
MacGyverOnline
Posted: 3 July 2007 - 12:16 PM                                    
Quote Post


Administrator
*********

Posts: 9,373
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:   ---
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: ---
Jacket:  ---
House:  ---



Not much difference really

Tinker

Large blade , small blade, can opener, small screwdriver, Bottle opener, large screwdriver, wire stripper, reamer/punch, Phillips screwdriver, tweezers, toothpick

Super Tinker

Has all the above plus Scissors and a hook.. and the reamer/punch has a sewing eye.



Join the MacGyver Online Network

Facebook ~ X ~ Instagram

 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
abacab
Posted: 5 July 2007 - 08:43 AM                                    
Quote Post


Trouble shooter
**

Posts: 74
Joined: 5 Jul 2007
Gender:  Male
Country: Pango Pango
SAK owned: Traveller

Favorites
Season: season 4
Episode: The Invisible Killer
Vehicle: Truck
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



I have a Wenger Traveller, bought in some factory-outlets north of Toronto. Features a blade, scissors, the tri-feature screwdriver thing, corkscrew, reamer, can opener, nail file, tweezers and (everybody's favorite) the reusable toothpick. I used to have a knockoff with some corporate logo on it ($10 from a pawn shop) that also had a Phillips head screwdriver and a wood saw, but some jerk stole it.



"I didn't think you'd be one to go for whipped bean curd." -Mac

 
PM                                                                     
Top
lee
Posted: 22 December 2009 - 01:58 AM                                    
Quote Post


Challengers Volunteer
*

Posts: 19
Joined: 30 Nov 2009
Gender:  Male
Country: Croatia, Europe
SAK owned: Tinker

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode: Could never make up my mind
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



I put together a simple table that shows witch sak mac used how many times, this is towards the list from this site.
Hope it helps someone a bit to pick there next SAK! wink.gif

user posted image



"It's a little recipe I use in emergencies"

 
PM                                                                     
Top
MacGyverOnline
Posted: 16 January 2010 - 03:59 PM                                    
Quote Post


Administrator
*********

Posts: 9,373
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:   ---
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: ---
Jacket:  ---
House:  ---



Good idea. smile.gif

I'm guessing the list isn't complete though because the numbers only add up to 90? Or do you mean it's based on what we have listed so far?




Join the MacGyver Online Network

Facebook ~ X ~ Instagram

 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
MacDriver
Posted: 22 January 2010 - 08:18 PM                                    
Quote Post


DXS Operative
****

Posts: 377
Joined: 31 May 2006
Gender:  Male
Country: Indiana
SAK owned: Sportsman

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:The Heist
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



I am as SAK crazy as it gets- if I told you how many I own, you literally would not believe me. I have carried one around daily for just over 10 years now, and I use them at least once a day.

Personally, I have landed in a very particular place that is specific to me needs and uses, and that is pretty much what will happen to anyone I think. I will tell you what a lot of SAK enthusiasts think.

First of all, with any full size SAK not the champ you have to decide between the corkscrew and the phillips. It is notable that you can use the flat screwdriver at the tip of the can opener for phillips screws- meaning if you get a model with a corkscrew, you still have a blade that will work for phillips screws. It cannot, however, go down into recessed holes, and it cannot handle extreme use as the can opener is a flat blade that with serious effort can twist and tweak a little. So the two main reasons for getting a knife with a corkscrew are that you drink wine, or you wear glasses/work on tiny things frequently and need the tiny screwdriver that can be screwed into the corkscrew:

user posted image

Next you have to ask yourself where you want to keep it- on your belt? In your pocket? Do you want it to be as small and light as possible? Or do you not mind a large bulky knife?

Two layer knives are considered the best for pocket carry. There knives include the Tinker, Spartan, Compact, Sportsman, Tourist, Recruit, and Soldier.

Three layer knives are not too bad, but this is the largest most people want to have in their pocket: Climber, Camper, Super Tinker, Hiker, Spartan Lite, Mechanic (although this one is almost as thick as a 4 layer), and few others are all good choices if you want a saw or scissors along with the basic Spartan/Tinker set of functions.

Think of it this way: The Tinker and the Spartan are "core" knives- every 91mm knife starts with one of those two toolsets and adds layers- saws, scissors, drivers, etc.

The 84mm line, Sportsman, Tinker Small, Tourist, and Recruit, are all great knives if you want full size features with slightly less bulk. THey are not as heavy duty, so you first have to settle if you are okay with that.

Personally, I would recommend a Super Tinker if that is catching your eye and you are wanting just one SAK. If you don't mind splitting it up between two SAKs (a common move) then a Classic SD/Signature on your keychain and a Tinker/Mechanic in your pocket is one of my favorite setups. Basically, you save a LOT of thickness by moving the scissors off the big knife and down to the little one. You also gain a ball point pen if you get a signature/manager keychain sized SAK.

Some people don't like the bulk of the pliers, but I really do not mind. I would say my most carried knife is a Mechanic with an Executive on my keys. So if you want to know what a "seasoned heavy SAK user" has boiled it down to, that's it. Well actually I modified my mechanic, but more or less it's still a Mechanic with just a couple of extra features. I plan to swap the phillips back in. Here is a pic:

user posted image

If you ever, after trying several models, decide you want something very particular that Victorinox does not offer, I can put a knife together in the configuration you are looking for. Just message me if you ever end up that SAK crazy tongue.gif

There you have it, my two cents worth. If you can handle it, get a Victorinox Spirit- they are just awesome. I would argue it is the best multitool for sale today. Obviously the Swiss Champ has it all, but they are as cumbersome as they appear, so ask yourself what you are really looking for.

Well an online gear reviewer uses a checklist to review things like knives and has a category he calls "philosophy of use"- basically I would say this is most important. If you are never more than a minute from your car, buy a champ to keep in there, and carry a Sportsman for the small stuff. Or if you go on long voyages into the woods, a one hand trekker might be a good choice. It's all about getting as many tools/features as you can in a practical size for what you want to haul around in your unique, personal lifestyle. Some people really just buy an Ambassador and that is all they need. Others want to be prepared all the time, like my friend who carries a Swiss Champ daily to his office job in dress clothes! Then there's guys like me who like a balance and I look at my plan for the day, then pick a SAK based on that, with it typically being the same knife unless I feel a particular event, ie a trip into the woods, could necessitate a particular feature, like a wood saw.

Examples I'll use- an EMT would want to carry a Rescue Tool. A Doctor would probably want a Compact, the thinnest full size SAK to offer scissors. A coin collector/jeweler would carry an Explorer, the smallest SAK with a magnifier. A carpenter would want a Camper/Hiker, the smallest SAK with a wood saw. A person who eats a lot of oranges would want an Executive on their keys to have an orange peeler handy all the time. A mom who is always changing batteries in her kids toys would want a Rambler to turn the tiny screws found in children's toys. A computer technician would undoubtedly want a Cybertool 29/34.

It's all in your lifestyle, then you ask yourself how much you want to be prepared for the unexpected, and how much comfort your willing to give up to achieve that.

Again, my advice for a first time SAK buy is one of the following combos:

Sportsman/Rambler
Tinker/Classic
Spartan/Rambler
Mechanic/Executive (if you don't mind slightly larger knives)

You cannot go wrong buying a SAK though, just stay away from knives that cheat you out of features, like the Recruit (get a small tinker, sprtsman, or tourist instead)- and if you get a keychain sized SAk to complement your large SAK, rather than the redundancy of having a toothpick on both knives, opt for a keychain knife that replaces the toothpick with the ball point pen. Get as many features as you can, while repeating as few as possible.

I probably sound like a mall ninja for carrying on this long about SAKs, but you asked tongue.gif



"It's a real ugly thing to see in a dog. It's even worse in a human being." --The Golden Triangle

"I'd like a 16-inch pizza, run it through the garden, hold the chovies." -- The Eraser

 
PM                                                                     
Top
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
 0 Members:
     

 Topic Options Reply to this topicStart new topicStart Poll