With the new Knight Rider pilot about to go into post-production and a remake of the Bionic women already on American screens, we can start to get an idea of Hollywood’s current mode of operation.
The bionic woman is a complete “make over” of the original series. It starts right back at the beginning with Jamie Summers wrecking her car, and herself and being “rebuilt” using today’s cutting edge technology. This new version has not only combined both the six million dollar man and women together (Jamie has a bionic eye as well as ear) but has also borrowed heavily from another similar short lived show called Jake 2.0. In this show the hero (Jake) was injected with nanobots, which give him bionic like abilities. Bionic women has also employed the nanobots which repair her body at an accelerated rate.
While the new Knight Rider has chosen to continue on from the original series, it too has not only updated the story to fit modern times and technology, but also borrowed heavily from another similar show called Viper. Like the Viper, the new Kitt car will be able to morph between operational modes (hero and attack) as well as employing the Vipers weaponry, holographic decoy and some form of remote control Reconnaissance Drone. Luckily the producers are also keeping the features of the original kitt which are really the icons of the show, the Artificial Intelligence system, which allows Kitt to talk, drive himself, think etc.
Both of these shows give an indication that Hollywood TV may be moving into a remake and update mode which got me thinking about a remake, or an update of MacGyver.
The pattern seems to be that they are combining similar shows as part of the “new improved” show. It’s hard to think of a show similar to MacGyver, because after all, they made it as a unique idea for a show. The obvious combination would be the never aired Young MacGyver with the original MacGyver using the ever so convenient character of SAM, MacGyver’s long lost son as the main character.
There have been other recent shows which have been referenced to have MacGyver like aspects to them, but these relate mostly to the characters MacGyverism abilities and no so much for other aspects such as the brains over violence theme MacGyver carried.
Like Knight Rider, a new MacGyver show would hit some stiff competition from the die hard fans of the original show, and could quite possibly even go through a failure such as the Team Knight Rider show and KR2000 movie before ‘would be’ producers finally get a clue and do it right. The Young MacGyver show could certainly be counted as a failure on par with Team Knight Rider. It was all to obvious that the producers had very little idea of the original show, nor seemed to have any real care to find out about it.
Let’s hope that if we do get a chance to see a new MacGyver on our screens its done with the same care and attention to the original shows, that the current remakes are showing.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
They must be very desperate in Hollywood if they're running out of ideas. And now... remaking TV-shows?
There's only one original actor to play a character. Don't touch what's perfect. However I did some score searching on allmovie on MacGyver, Magnum PI and Xena Warrior Princess. MacGyver scored the least of them all with only 2,5 stars, Magnum had 3 stars and Xena scored the most of them all with 3,5 stars. I was fairly surprised of these scores with MacGyver scoring so low. MacGyver scores as much as an R-rated trash film. Than again I'm not so surprised. Magnum is in many ways better than MacGyver and much more daring. In Magnum emotions are better acted, his women clients are done better and Magnum faces his past demons from 'Nam more than once in a season. In MacGyver you should get lucky to have such an episode like Blood Brothers for instance. There are only a few episodes where they dare to go deep into it like Humanity.
Also what lacks MacGyver are bigger storylines. Magnum has had till as far as I know at least one two-parter every season. MacGyver only one every two seasons with the exception of the first two. We have Lost Love, Legend of the Holy Rose and Good Knight MacGyver. Come to think of it, more Lost Love style adventures involving Mac, Jack and Pete in the city would've been nice.
Not only more two parters would have improved the series but major storylines as well. If I think back to Xena's third season with Gabrielle's pregnancy and giving birth to an evil offspring, I can't help but wonder did the writers of MacGyver did their best? Of course they did but I think they should've seen things on much grander scale. Xena's third season story line covered six episodes spread out through the season. It all started with The Deliverer episode, Gabrielle losing her innocence and getting pregnant, she delivers the baby in Gabrielle's Hope, lied to Xena, Xena lied back to her in the two-parter The Debt causing a massive rift between the two in Maternal Instinct & The Bitter Suite. Those two episodes marks the return of Hope as a nine year old. She looked like nine. Gabrielle killed her daughter than and later she comes back as a grown up woman looking like Gabrielle in the third's season two-parter finale Sacrifice with one hell of finale to keep fans wondering and hungry for the next season. The story continues in the first three episodes of the fourth season with the two-parter Adventures in the Sintrade where in Xena is looking for Gabrielle and in Family Affair, Gabrielle became a grandmother. Than later there were references in the fifth and sixth season and in the final season they even made a comedy episode to show what happened after Adventures in the Sintrade en before Family Affair. I think something like that would've been cool in MacGyver. Not that the seperate episodes were bad but I don't know. Bigger storylines, cliffhangers at seasons finale could have made the series more intense.
While on IMDB MacGyver nearly scores an 8/10 with 7,9/10, Magnum 7,7/10 and Xena 6,7/10.
Now I think there is a way to improve the show and that is to give it the latest television formula. Something that has the intensity of shows like 24, Lost and Prison Break. In this case Prison Break's level. A main character that can think. I once opened up a topic MacGyver vs Michael Scofield. I think in some ways they are very much alike. For as far as I recall Scofield never used a gun, with exception also in the Pilot to get himself busted to break out of prison with a big plan. A plan much better than Mac's in The Escape. So they can both think and they only fight when necessary. Though I have seen Scofield do things Mac would never do.
I think out of those three shows you can each take an ingredient. The races against time of 24, the tropical places for overseas assignments of Lost and the ways of planning from Prison Break.
Now on the actual idea of remaking the show. Does the show needs a remake? No. Not now anyway, it's way too early. And especially not if they're simply going to remake every single episode. I think first a movie on the big screens is of more importance to me than a new series. If the movie is a success than I think you can carefully consider another series. Of course a new cast is inevitable. And if you really work on it, it might work out. I think MacGyverisms now would be cool and they also would be more technically. But the way they treated MacGyver in it's release, they don't seem to care about him and a new approach might suck.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: Observatory
Ah yes- the wonder of TV show remakes. (And this kind of goes for movie remakes of TV shows too) - Generally the only good thing I can say about them is that they fuel interest in the original TV series and help get copyright holders to release such things as Season DVD sets of the original show and possibly other related merchandising that they never bothered to release when the show was originally running. But for the most part- there are few remakes that I really like. Remakes of movies are one thing- when it's the case of updating an older classic to modern times, that may be okay. (Example- "Miracle on 34th. Street"- I've seen both the 1947 original and the 1994 remake- both are good, with no huge differences that I can recall, other than the time period and the culture of that time period.) Then others are just plain unnecessary- I mean, how many versions of "Freaky Friday" does Disney really need to make? (There's been at least 3- the 1976 original, a 1998 TV-movie and the 2003 movie) But TV show remakes- and here you have to be careful to differentiate between spin-off shows and remakes- are generally never as good as the original series, in my opinion. There are some shows that are part of a franchise, such as Star Trek and its many spin-off shows (the best of which being Star Trek: The Next Generation, obviously ) and Saved By the Bell is another good example. And in those cases, I pretty much like all of the various series pretty equally. But then there's stuff like The Munsters Today and The New Addams Family- both kind of modern versions of the '60s classics. Neither one terribly bad, I suppose- but neither really terribly great either. But the recent Night Stalker series quickly died and went to the full series DVD release. I think I'd much rather see the original 1974 series (also on DVD)- Kolchak, the Night Stalker. Same deal with Battlestar Galactica, Kojak, Dragnet, The Bionic Woman, Knight Rider, G.I. Joe, Transformers, and so forth. (Though I take some exception with cartoons because although I'm much more of a fan of the original 1982 G.I. Joe series and 1984 Transformers series, at least with newer incarnations of the shows, you're generally gonna have the same characters in a similar if not the same continuity and still looking the same facially and such. Sometimes even the same voice actors return.) But I should also take back Knight Rider. I approach this with some cautious enthusiasm- I'll have to see how the show really goes when it airs- but I give it credit for maintaining continuity with the original series and keeping David Hasselhoff as Michael Knight (though he probably won't really be the main focus of the show) It'd be even better if they still had the black Pontiac Trans Am with William Daniels voicing KITT- but they transferred KITT to a newer model in the "Knight Rider 2000" TV-movie (and killed off Devon Miles' character- which is just as well at this point since Edward Mulhare has since passed on too.) But I'm not sure if they're considering this 1991 TV-movie to be part of the continuity- and who knows what the deal with "Team Knight Rider" is. I'd call that a spin-off series and leave it at that. I doubt there will be much if any connection made with that show. If the Young MacGyver series had actually had Dalton James as SAM, I probably would have been pretty psyched- especially if Richard Dean Anderson would come back as Angus MacGyver. That not being the case, I pretty much lost interest. (Though now it creates a bit of annoyance for those persnickety people that like to count any official production as part of canon history and want to have an archive of each such endeavor- in this case, an official release of the pilot as a bonus on a DVD set or such- but that probably won't ever happen. That's why we have Ebay! ) Okay- so basically what I'm saying is that if a new production actually maintains some continuity with the original show and uses the original actors and actresses in their original roles, then I give the show much more weight than that which merely replaces all the original people and possibly even changes the dynamics of the show by changing around the characters themselves. Of course, generally the only shows that maintain any continuity with the original shows are actually spin-offs rather than remakes, so therein lies the distinction. And same deal with movie versions of TV shows. Obviously the Star Trek movies are good because the same TV casts are used. Though this was not the case with the Mission: Impossible movies, I will say that given the nature of the storyline, I can understand why the original actors and actresses turned down cameo appearances (Let the characters live on in reruns!) And I actually do enjoy the Mission: Impossible movies because they're good action movies- but they don't quite have all the same feel of Mission: Impossible. Though speaking of this show, this is another example of a good remake/spin-off series. The 1960s series is great- and the revived 1980s series is also excellent! This is one example where they got it right! And the same actor was on hand to play Jim Phelps and the son of another returned to portray his character- so that's cool too. Also, in 2003 NBC did an incredible feat with bringing Fred Dryer back to star in a revived version of Hunter! (Why this hasn't been done with RDA in a new version of MacGyver, I don't know- other than RDA's apparent reluctance to take on the character again.) But for the few good remake movies and TV shows, there's movies like Starsky & Hutch, The Dukes of Hazzard, The Avengers (which I thought was okay, but I've never really seen much of the show so it's hard for me to accurately say), The Mod Squad, The Brady Bunch movies, Bewitched, The Honeymooners (nothing against an all-black version- just the PG-13 raunchiness), Scooby-Doo (even live action versions of cartoons would be included in this list- the 2nd. one is okay- but what they did in the first one was just wrong), Josie and the Pussycats (there's absolutely no reason that movie should have been PG-13), Lost in Space, and I'm sure there's others I forgot to mention. Though there are a few that are pretty decent like Flipper and Lassie (1994 movie versions), and The Flinstones movies. (Both are pretty good, but I'm disgusted to know that they just had to include one curse word in the first one so they could get that PG rating so they could get older kids to see the movie so they could get more money. At least it wasn't one of the main characters from the show cursing- but it doesn't matter- that was totally unnecessary and added absolutely nothing to the movie.) Oh yeah- and there's also an excellent 1990 TV-movie called "Archie: Return to Riverdale" that is an interesting live action version of the classic Archie comics. I should point out that this also gets a bit risque at points, but manages to stay pretty clean- after all, this is Archie! ) And I suppose the Underdog movie might be okay- and hopefully the Alvin and the Chipmunks movie is pretty decent. Haven't gotten around to checking these out quite yet, but I imagine I'll see them at some point. And who knows what we'll get with Steve Carey and Anne Hathaway in "Get Smart". Hopefully something decent, but I know it won't be Don Adams and Barbara Feldon. And as far as I know, there's supposed to be movie versions of The Equalizer, The A-Team and Magnum, P.I. still in the works. Just have to wait and see what comes of those. But if you want a really, incredibly awesome revival of a cool movie series- that is not a remake, but is actually a sequel which still stars the original actor in his famous adventuring role- then go check out Harrison Ford in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull on May 22, 2008!!! I can't wait!!!!
Posts: 1,960
Joined: 4 Mar 2006
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Super Tinker
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode: Widowmaker
Vehicle: Nomad
Jacket: Leather Biker
House: House boat
QUOTE (MacGyverGod @ 2 January 2008 - 02:44 PM)
They must be very desperate in Hollywood if they're running out of ideas. And now... remaking TV-shows?
Oh, they've doing that since War of the Worlds in the 1980's. That may not have been the first movie-to-TV to air, but it's the one I remember most. Very gritty. WAY too violent and bloody. They pulled it off the air amid various complaints. But I loved it. It was sci-fi...
Though I wasn't really a fan of Knight Rider, I did watch it occasionally. I stopped watching because I felt they focused on making the car the ultimate star when the relationship between KITT and Michael was why I first watched it. Not how hopped-up the car could be. Also the frequent cast changes were unnecessary. I just hate change, I guess. (I also liked the voice of William Daniels... Sorry, Rocky. I'm not a fan of David Hasselhoff, although I've read that they were in negotiations to reprise his role as Michael Knight... I remembered him more as Snapper in Y&R, back in the dark ages.)
Bionic Woman... I like both shows, though I think they should have given the lead of the new BW to Katee Sackhoff instead of Michelle Ryan. She just has more character, IMO.
I think the Magnum, PI remake is off the table with Tom Selleck taking over from James Caan in Las Vegas. *shrug*
As far as TV shows into movies, well... Star Trek nearly bit the bullet with the first movie. It was only the rabid fan behavior (yes, I was one of "them"...) that kept it going, and fortunately it hit paydirt in the second movie after that. That series of movies had an "every-other-movie-was-good" thing going on there. (I fell asleep in the theater with the first movie every single time; right after the "Klingon" music played. Snooooze! )
I really think the studio would to hard pressed to find someone to replace RDA as MacGyver. He's one of a kind... although, I was impressed with Michael Welch when he played a teenaged Jack O'Neill on Stargate. That boy had all RDA's and Jack O'Neill's mannerisms down to a T. If it came down to it, I'd take him in replacement of Dalton James any day. (Whatever happened to him anyway?)
I don't know if I would want to have a remake of the series or a continuation. Either way, I don't think RDA is willing to get in the MacGyver mindset anytime soon, if ever. He seems to fight it all the way, except when they allowed him to inject some humor in the character, like in the AMEX commercial.
You know, M'God... I really have to watch Prison Break. To hear you tell about it, the show is great. It must run against something else I watch...
What was the original question?
"My Jeep went over a cliff, I died... and went to Thanksgiving?"
I really think the studio would to hard pressed to find someone to replace RDA as MacGyver. He's one of a kind... although, I was impressed with Michael Welch when he played a teenaged Jack O'Neill on Stargate. That boy had all RDA's and Jack O'Neill's mannerisms down to a T. If it came down to it, I'd take him in replacement of Dalton James any day.
Hey, there's an idea! And here was I only thinking all the time "if Wylie only had been a boy!"
But I'd go with Michael Welch every time, too! He really was just great. But I think he has a regular series right now, already, also.
QUOTE
You know, M'God... I really have to watch Prison Break. To hear you tell about it, the show is great. It must run against something else I watch...
Oh yeah, you must! I highly recommend that one, too. But you must start at the beginning, otherwise it would not make much sense, I'm afraid. In Germany we are in the middle of the second season right now, and I just love it. Very suspensing, you just want to know how it will continue, and Michael indeed is some kind of MacGyver.
How he had planned everything from the start and how he then had to adjust when things didn't work out... great actors, great storyline, I was drawn to it right from the beginning.
I wish there was a Prison-Break-convention one day.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
And as far as I know, there's supposed to be movie versions of The Equalizer, The A-Team and Magnum, P.I. still in the works. Just have to wait and see what comes of those.
Magnum is in a very early state but if it's due to 2009 they better hurry. Tom Selleck is probably out of the question. While they rather should cast the original stars. The four are all still alive. Higgins probably walks with a cane by now. But they're all alive and I hope Donald P. Bellisario is also still around. He was there from the beginning wrote upon till now what I've seen the best episodes. I think he should at least write the scenario and direct it. The A-Team is also in an early state but more solid.
QUOTE
But if you want a really, incredibly awesome revival of a cool movie series- that is not a remake, but is actually a sequel which still stars the original actor in his famous adventuring role- then go check out Harrison Ford in Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull on May 22, 2008!!! I can't wait!!!!
I hope movies like this are made more often and get Hollywood are to realise that whatever's old is not written down. Sylvester Stallone has proven this with Rocky Balboa and Bruce Willis with Die Hard 4.0. However Bruce Willis never really lost his shape and his career never went down the drain. I'm sure Stallone will prove it again with John Rambo and I feel Harrison Ford and Steven Spielberg won't let down there fans.
QUOTE
You know, M'God... I really have to watch Prison Break. To hear you tell about it, the show is great. It must run against something else I watch...
Yeah, do check it out, you won't regret it.
QUOTE
What was the original question?
A modern update or remake of MacGyver. To be, or not to be... That's the question!
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:Jack in the Box (...possibly!)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
If they are updating it then I’d be worried they would go too much along the clever gadgets and cutting edge technology route. The MacGyverisms involving common everyday stuff that is lying around would have to stay. I wouldn’t want MacGyver running about with James Bond style gadgets or anything. If they did create a MacGyver movie I hope they don’t ham it up or make it cheesy. I want it to be exciting and clever. I will always have Richard Dean Anderson in my mind when I think of MacGyver and I may be more accepting of a movie with the same sort of premise as MacGyver than a movie where a new actor is playing MacGyver. A non-violent adventurer who uses his brain to create clever solutions for puzzles or problems. It wouldn’t have to be called MacGyver for that to be a film I’d want to watch.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE (Macs Lab Rat @ 3 January 2008 - 08:52 PM)
If they are updating it then I’d be worried they would go too much along the clever gadgets and cutting edge technology route. The MacGyverisms involving common everyday stuff that is lying around would have to stay. I wouldn’t want MacGyver running about with James Bond style gadgets or anything. If they did create a MacGyver movie I hope they don’t ham it up or make it cheesy. I want it to be exciting and clever. I will always have Richard Dean Anderson in my mind when I think of MacGyver and I may be more accepting of a movie with the same sort of premise as MacGyver than a movie where a new actor is playing MacGyver. A non-violent adventurer who uses his brain to create clever solutions for puzzles or problems. It wouldn’t have to be called MacGyver for that to be a film I’d want to watch.
There's always National Treasure and the boys from Sahara. However in Sahara I think Steve Zahn was using a rifle in the end.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: Observatory
Oh, I would definitely recommend National Treasure: Book of Secrets! It's just as good, if not better, than the first one! Lots of great action, good storyline, drama, suspense, and a nice focus on American history, which is pretty cool to see. (Of course, it's also thrown in with conspiracy theory stuff too- but that's part of the fun.) And I don't believe there's a single curse word in the whole movie! It's very hard to find such a clean PG rated movie like that that still offers lots of action and adventure and is not just aimed at kids. The first movie certainly had some MacGyver moments. I'm not sure if that was as prevalent in the sequel, but it's still worth seeing. Well, I'll say this. I can't think of many "MacGyverisms" from the movie offhand- but the way Ben Gates puts the clues together and pulls off such things like kidnapping the President of the United States of America- there's definitely a MacGyver feel there in the way he does it.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
It is a Walt Disney film after all. And after what I've seen in the trailer, things sure look all right. The action seems much more rousing but after all, no language.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:The Widowmaker
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Just a note on Sahara from a very serious Dirk Pitt fan...
For the love of all that is holy, READ THE BOOK.
The least they could've done was make Dirk's hair and eyes the right color, esp his eyes. I'm all for artistic license, and from what I understand Clive Cussler (the author) was pretty happy with the film (and that's what really matters-Dirk is his creation, after all), unlike the only other movie made from his books (Raise The Titanic) long ago, but still...I mean, Dirk's 'opaline green eyes' are one of his trademarks. Right along with his Colt 45 and classic automobiles. I enjoyed the movie, and my husband really liked it, but, as always, the book was far better.
It was an enjoyable movie, but...um...READ THE BOOK.
And while you're at it, read all of Clive Cussler's books...or at least all of the Dirk Pitt novels. I have a feeling this group would like them.
As for National Treasure, my husband is in love with that movie, but we haven't seen the second one yet. I enjoyed the film, but not to the level he did. I do like the mystery and using the brain part of it, though. Much more fun that bang-bang shoot 'em ups, in my opinion.
Oh, and as for TV remakes or movies from TV shows or TV shows from movies....general rule...I wish no one would make them. They are generaly terrible. Spin-offs are different, although many of them stink, too.
The exceptions, of course, are out there, and the first I think of are the Star Trek series, which stand on their own feet, and the one...the only...STARGATE.
"Now, come on, Pete! Look at me! I'm a hurtin' guy! I'm beat up! I need a month's worth of sleep! And I need a haircut!" MacGyver, 'Serenity'
Posts: 194
Joined: 11 Dec 2006
Gender: Female
Country: Land of Confusion
SAK owned: Climber
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I, too, LOVED Sahara. It was great! Didn't know that there was a book. I will definitely have to check that out!
As to the question of a remake or continuation of MacGyver....I dunno. After seeing what they tried to do with Young MacGyver, I have to say that my vote would be NO. Come on, they couldn't even get the facts straight. If MacGyver was an only child, where did a nephew (Clay) come from? If they didn't want to use his son (SAM), they could of at least said that Clay was MacGyver's "little brother"---like in the Pilot episode.
I honestly don't think that there could be another MacGyver. Only my 2 cents.
Favorites
Season: season 2
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Bet you guys thought I was dead or something! lol!
I'm a little skeptical, too, that there should be a Mac movie. I'd love for it to be done right, and I think if whoever maybe kinda sorta would do it took cues from movies like National Treasure and Sahara it'd be worth seeing. I don't wanna see MacGyver all dark and edgy and sexed up and full of swearing if that's what updating it will mean. As far as current technology shooting the idea of MacGyverisms in the foot...I don't think that would be the case...he'd just have more complex things to rip apart and do something with...
I haven't been following the whole Knight Rider thing, even tho I was a pretty avid fan, but I am following some of the GI Joe movie talk. I think there's gonna be a lot of unhappy fans...probably me included. I look at Transformers...which, in spite of a LOT of nitpicks I have (surprise surprise, right?) was a pretty good movie...Lots of people were up in arms about it coming out, but were pleasantly surprised how faithful it was to the mythos...but they had to go and "update it" with a scantily dressed girl who could barely act, vulgarity, and enough sex talk that my 8 year old who loves the toys won't be seeing it, and is REALLY upset about it. That's what I'm talking about with MacGyver...I don't think I could stand that kind of updating. That also worries me about the Joe movie...kiddo loves, GI Joe, too, but I seriously doubt he'll get to see it. If the trend holds and MacGyver happens, they'll probably be just faithful enough to please diehard fans, but they'll have to make it just "bad" enough to get the older rating. Heck, I'm an adult...if TF had had none of the unsavory crap in it, I'd have still seen it just because of the name, and after seeing it once, I just might have been back at the theater a few more times...
"It's amazing what one can do when one doesn't know what one can't do." Garfield the Cat
"Another day, a whole 'nother set of fresh possibilities. I'm a sucker for mornings." MacGyver
I discovered Dirk by accident in the local library. I think with Night Probe or Raise The Titanic, but I'm not positive. I then read every Cussler book I could find and now I await any new ones anxiously. The last few Dirk novels haven't been quite as good as the earlier ones for me (although the very latest one-Treasure of Khan-was very enjoyable), but still worth a read. The NUMA files books have a different set of heroes (Kurt Austin and gang), as do the Oregon files. I've read only some of those books. They are good, too, but I loves me my Dirk, so....
Anyway.
My vote still goes for no remake of Mac, and for the record I thought Transformers was just ok. A nice way to kill a few hours, and not a bad flick at all, but a one time only movie for me.
"Now, come on, Pete! Look at me! I'm a hurtin' guy! I'm beat up! I need a month's worth of sleep! And I need a haircut!" MacGyver, 'Serenity'
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
Bet you guys thought I was dead or something! lol!
Yeah, started to think so. Glad you're back.
QUOTE
I'm a little skeptical, too, that there should be a Mac movie. I'd love for it to be done right, and I think if whoever maybe kinda sorta would do it took cues from movies like National Treasure and Sahara it'd be worth seeing. I don't wanna see MacGyver all dark and edgy and sexed up and full of swearing if that's what updating it will mean. As far as current technology shooting the idea of MacGyverisms in the foot...I don't think that would be the case...he'd just have more complex things to rip apart and do something with...
What I actually don't want to see is a Mac movie in style of National Treasure. Not another Indy-ish adventure. But I can understand what you mean. It should be of that level.
Dark? Well, I like dark. But dark is not immediately something for a big comeback on the big screen.
Sexed up and full of swearing neither. Of course there will probably be a girl being all that but I don't know. Just wouldn't fit unless done right. Someone like Kate Connolly perhaps but we don't want it like MacGyver's Women. There are plenty of women out there who can be smart and pretty at the same time. I remember a certain Nikki Carpenter out there.
On scenario: I'd say a decent rescue scenario or maybe a big assignment. Or something like the final clash between Mac and Murdoc. I wonder if they can come up with an intelligent scenario like the first Mission Impossible film. OK, that was an actioner and the scenario requiered some thinking. So maybe if that screenwiter can write something. I think it was written by David Koepp who now just wrote Indy 4.
And if it comes to ratings... an R-rating is out of the question. A PG-13 is debatable and a PG would be maybe just too perfect. Then again there are more PG-s they you might think. Five of the six Rocky movies are PG's. And still you have the blood at the end. They're swearingless and very entertaining. National Treasure is also PG and swearingless for the most part if not entirely. Indiana Jones has some brief swearing but were PG, the first two I know. It's thanks to The Temple of Doom PG-13 came in the ratings list.
Anyway, if they wanna make a film about MacGyver, one thing is for sure. They'll have A LOT to talk about before they should begin. I do mean A LOT and I do mean TALK.
So possible crew for it. I don't know. Cautiously choosen for director: Martin Campbell (considering from Vertical Limit and Casino Royal), Jon Turteltaub (nice shot with National Treasure, don't know about the sequel, maybe giving him a chance has a little to somewhat risk) or perhaps the director of Sahara. Michael Bay, hmmm. Transformers was in my opinion a very good movie, but than again I'm not so familiar with the cartoons. Hey, pssst. W. Morgan Sheppard was Captain Witwicky. Michael Bay is debatable but not likely. J.J. Abrahams from Lost. He might make a good actioner of it but PG-13 probably.
Screenwriters: David Koepp would be nice. Chances are small it would be an Indy-like story. If he can live it up to the level of the first Mission Impossible. However I'd choose not to have anything with going undercover. Paul Haggis. He did Million Dollar Baby, Crash and Casino Royale. I think he might be a good choice. Minor risk. Jonathan Hensleigh if he can live it up to the level of Die Hard With A Vengeance. That was an actioner R-rated however but with one heck of scenario. It was like the perfect robbery. J.J. Abrahams again because of Mission Impossible III and Armageddon.
Music composers. My first choice would be Ken Harrison of course or Dennis McCarthy or Randy Edelman. Or the three of them and each giving their scenes they can compose. Randy Edelman, I can deal with that. He made the theme song after all. He never did anything big though. Last of the Mohicans, The Bruce Lee Story, Anaconda and Triple X. James Newton Howard (with or without Hans Zimmer). If you just listen to the first track of Batman Begins, you'll understand why. If you hear it, it'll fit perfect over a MacGyverism/escape scene. Trevor Rabin the man behind National Treasure, if it's in further style of his elder works like Deep Blue Sea and National Treasure of course. Clint Mansell from Sahara. He has proven that he can do more than just playing depressing music as in Requiem for a Dream. If it would be JJ Abraham it'll probably be Michael Giacchino. When watching Lost I take notice of the music and it's very good. Especially the creepy sound of the last few episodes in the third season still rings through my ears.
God so many possibilities and probably not used, good or thought over enough.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Favorites
Season: season 2
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Guess I maybe took the wrong angle on this refocusing on movie, when the original idea was about a TV show! Well, at any rate, whatever I said stands even for a TV series. You know, sadly enough, I didn't realize that Knight Rider was going to be a series! I assumed it was a movie...geez I've been outta the loop on some things! Anyway, I realized it when hubby and I were watching TV last night and there was a very short teaser for it...just a couple of shots of the car (which hubby was very excited to see was a Mustang...at least he said so...I barely caught it, it was so short) and then the car said "Hello, Mike." Needless to say hubby's stoked and I'm sure we'll be checking it out.
I tried to watch Bionic Woman...really, I did. It just didn't do anything for me...I guess I just don't see why all the swearing's necessary and I get distracted by it. You could argue that it's just how people talk nowadays, but, I don't buy it. I know very few people who do. I'd hate to see that happen to MacGyver. Dark? I have no problem with dark cuz I'm just twisted enough to enjoy that kind of thing...but I don't want a whole MacGyver series without the trademark tongue in cheek humor. I finally got to see the TV movies recently, and I much preferred the feel of Atlantis because it had the subtle humor... And yeah, MG, I don't want a Mac version of National Treasure or Sahara, but something of that caliber. They managed to draw in adults but keep it clean (Sahara a little less) for children and just go all out on the adventure.
"It's amazing what one can do when one doesn't know what one can't do." Garfield the Cat
"Another day, a whole 'nother set of fresh possibilities. I'm a sucker for mornings." MacGyver
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Actually we're talking always about the swearing. If it's like in the third season, it won't bother me. The d-word or the h-word but it must depend on it's usage. When I last saw Early Retirement I noticed how much they swore.
QUOTE
It just didn't do anything for me...I guess I just don't see why all the swearing's necessary and I get distracted by it.
Actually it's less and less. There are more and more PG-13's with only one F-word in it. That's what I call stupid. It's like: 'Hence it's only PG-13 but we wanna say it at least once.' Than I figure: 'Hey, say it either multiple times and make the movie rated R or else don't use that word in a PG-13 because it's not helping.' I grew up with R-rated films and saw movies like Lethal Weapon 4 and Bad Boys II before or when I was just 17 and actually I never noticed it. It's now I started to notice when they swore, especially with later films like Blood Diamond and The Kingdom.
I found it slightly disappointing when Die Hard 4.0 came out as a PG-13 and I even heard Bruce Willis wasn't happy about that either. I just find it always disgracing to the tradition of the R-rating films. This also goes for taglines of movies. Like the gunshot over the last half of the word or as in Alien vs. Predator that thanks to Paul WS Anderson ruined the tagline of Predator by cutting the word in half. Sometimes I wished we were back in the early nineties. A lot more was allowed back than. Did had a good time though with Die Hard 4.0. But hey, there's always the unrated version.
Still in MacGyver swearing is a no-no. For me acceptable is as it was in the third season. But calling names out of habit like in most R-rated flicks. No way.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
Well I have to say, I find it quite disturbing that someone would actually miss swearing and violence in a movie. that doesn't strike me as a healthy mind set at all.
Depends on what kind of movie and on which audience it's targeted. I'd say it gives some extra power to the film. I can't imagine a film like 8MM or Running Scared without swearing or violence. Those movies shows the dark side of the city or certain environments, I don't think either of those movies would be as good as without swearing.
I can watch any rated film. But after what I just wrote you might not be surprised that most of my dvd's are R-rated. I'm action lover kinda guy. Good cop/bad cop, violence, humor. That's my style and I don't fear darker movies either.
QUOTE
I don't understand that at all. NORMAL people don't swear constantly, and it baffles me as to why TV shows have to have so much bad language in them.
As if you don't swear every now and then. Like when you hit your head or been clumsy and end up hurting yourself.
Do tell me which tv-shows has got bad language in them. Not counting HBO shows but shows from the 80's and 90's. maybe Miami Vice. There was swearing in the movie, don't know about the series though.
Xena had some episodes where they pronounced the b-word.
Recentely Lost has also every now and than bad language. On one example (don't know if you have seen it though) Ben fooled Sawyer in making him believe they planted a pacemaker in his chest. He even had a scar and a heart rate beeper. When Sawyer found out it wasn't true, he really swung that left fist in his face and called him a someone of a someone.
I think if you were in Sawyer's place, you would react the same way. Or would you say something like: 'Yo-yo'. Imagine I hit you in the nose and blood an everything is coming out. Would you say: 'Yo-yo'? or 'goon'? I think you're going to say something else and something less nice.
QUOTE
It would be very disappointing if they gave MacGyver that kind of make-over
But I fully agree with you on that one. You see it all depends on what your aiming for, which audience. MacGyver will do terrific on a PG-rating and he will do good as well on a PG-13. There are many PG-13's out there that has no bad language in them (Casino Royale, King Kong, LOTR, Jurassic Park... etc and they're rousing, adventreous, tense and funny) but the scenario's are heavier or not suitable for younger ones. But I think MacGyver will do well enough on a PG-13. After all that's where in some episodes the target lies. Kids in troubles. You shouldn't show six year olds what the effects of alcohol are or what drugs can do to you. 13 and 14 year olds can understand that (better).
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Posts: 1,960
Joined: 4 Mar 2006
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Super Tinker
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode: Widowmaker
Vehicle: Nomad
Jacket: Leather Biker
House: House boat
It's a testament to how used I've become to the fact that I no longer even hear the swearing. It's so commonplace in all but a few shows, and that bothers me that I've turned a blind "ear" to it...
But modern Hollywood will actually add a curse word or add a modicum of nudity to a movie or show to raise the ratings, even when the movie is geared toward children. G-rated ratings just doesn't get the audience that will pay the big bucks.
Disney, so far, has kept to its base audience, but it's big enough not to have to worry... yet.
ANYWAY... The d-word and the h-word are normally not considered swearing these days, in television. I still wouldn't want to see it in any incarnation of MacGyver. I have considered, for the most part, MacGyver as "clean" television.
"My Jeep went over a cliff, I died... and went to Thanksgiving?"
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: Observatory
QUOTE
ANYWAY... The d-word and the h-word are normally not considered swearing these days, in television. I still wouldn't want to see it in any incarnation of MacGyver. I have considered, for the most part, MacGyver as "clean" television.
Hmm- seems that just shows what's become commonplace and acceptable in society- or at least on that magical world that exists in television- which certainly does not always (if ever) really reflect reality. (Yes, even on those "reality" shows.) Aside from the few curse words MacGyver uses in the first season- and a few words used by Pete from time to time or the bad guys throughout the series- MacGyver is by far a very clean show- both in language, as well as in the case of sexuality and violence and such. Any movie or TV series made based on MacGyver should reflect that. Too many of the remakes of '60s, '70s and '80s TV series have not reflected that- and have not stayed true to the original show- which is why I dislike the vast majority of TV show "remake" movies. As far as continuing MacGyver goes, my opinion is probably three options. Either get Richard Dean Anderson to agree to reprise his role of MacGyver in a new theatrical movie OR get Dalton James to reprise his role as SAM in a new TV series (with Richard Dean Anderson returning in a supporting role as MacGyver) OR both!
But otherwise, I don't know that I would be terribly interested in any other sort of remake, other than just for the fact that it would bear MacGyver's name- and for that reason alone, I might check it out intially for completist's reasons- but not much beyond that.
I don't understand that at all. NORMAL people don't swear constantly, and it baffles me as to why TV shows have to have so much bad language in them.
As if you don't swear every now and then. Like when you hit your head or been clumsy and end up hurting yourself.
Read what I said.. "don't swear constantly"
QUOTE
Do tell me which tv-shows has got bad language in them. Not counting HBO shows but shows from the 80's and 90's.
I was talking about shows on TV today.
Here in New Zealand we get all the blockbuster movies broadcast on TV several months after they hit the DVD market, and they are never edited, they contain all the original swearing, violence etc. I hate it.
When I was a kid the movies where edited to fit the broadcasting standards.. now, apparently, they don't have any standards.
I think the lack of morals displayed on out TV screens is directly responsible for our societies decay, our kids see and hear things on TV and so assume it must be acceptable, otherwise why would it be on TV?
That and the fact that most parents can't actually be bothered to raise their kids any more!
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
Here in New Zealand we get all the blockbuster movies broadcast on TV several months after they hit the DVD market, and they are never edited, they contain all the original swearing, violence etc. I hate it.
Than at least you know you're watching the original version with everything in it where it belongs.
Don't tell me you don't like to see guns blazing, fist fights and car crashes?
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Posts: 7,214
Joined: 3 Dec 2005
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Camper&Swissbit
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I find the amount of graphic violence and sex on TV shocking, indeed. When I was a kid, the worse you would ever hear on TV was 'hell'... and that was considered strong language!
Now, don't get me wrong... I like an unedited movie. Language, sex, violence... these things don't annoy me if I know to expect them.
But seeing that on TV... where the kids can turn it on and watch without supervision... that seems a bad thing to me. Children are too young to be exposed to that... it desensitized them, and we wind up with violent, confused teenagers who have no sense of self-discipline or moral standards. Before you know it... they're being handed Darwin Awards... posthumously.
~~~
On the subject of a MacGyver remake... if they could somehow reproduce the spirit of the original show, I'd definitely watch it. I am profoundly sceptical of whether or not this is possible... but I felt the same way about many other 'remakes' that have been accomplished. Some suck, true... but some are jewels, complimenting and honouring the original production.
I'd have to give it a chance.
Everyone, sometimes, needs a camel.
Old troubleshooters never die... They just wait til the last moment and then rescue themselves!
Posts: 2,949
Joined: 11 Nov 2006
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I've been following this thread for a couple of days now and find everyone's comments quite interesting.
As far as swearing goes, I know we've had this conversation before. Contemporary movies use nudity, swearing and violence as filler and distraction for movies that lack engaging writing and a decent plot.
I agree with you Rock, that the standards for broadcast television have relaxed considerably these last 20 years. The junk that passes for entertainment these days is appalling in its mediocrity and crassness. Its one of the main reasons that I don't have cable or satellite TV. Unfortunately, its also one of the most successful imports the United States has, but that's a topic for another day.
Swearing and rudeness are commmonplace because we no longer shame people who use the F word and its friends in public. In the 70's and early 80's, swearing was frowned upon, and adults, including complete strangers, held each other and young people accountable for their words. doing so today is likely to land you in a fight or get you shot for not minding your own business.
Contemporary movies and TV reflect the values of contemporary society. These values may be positive or negative, but they are incorporated into modern entertainment. Because we are so desensitized to the negative, swearing, violence and nudity are further amplified and magnified to increase their shock/emotional response on the viewer. The more extreme the violence, swearing and nudity in entertainment, the more these behaviors are incorporated into society and considered 'normal' and 'acceptible'.
Of course it doesn't help that celebrities who have no moral compass are embraced and rewarded for their bad behavior by the 'news' media. These people then become role models for children and youth and thus the negative behaviors are further reinforced and rewarded.
So how can those of us who are parents fight back? The only way the entertainment industry can understand. Do not support entertainment that is not in alignment with your own values. Do not buy, rent, or attend in a theater, movies you find offensive. Do not watch TV shows you find offensive. Monitor and censor what your children view. If you wouldn't take your child to see it in the theater, don't rent it and watch it together at home. If enough people do these things, and demand suitable entertainment, then things will change. My biggest fear is that we are too late and that most people are too numbed and dumbed by the trivial crap served as entertainment to care or to take action.
I have a strict policy on the types of movies and TV shows I let my 4 year old watch. I came home one afternoon and my husband, nephew, his girlfriend and my brother-in-law were all watching Casino Royale, with my 4 year old son. You're right MG that this movie doesn't have a lot of swearing, however it is extremely violent and completely uinsuitable for a child. To say that I pitched a coniption fit would be an understatement. The scary part of it all is that the guys didn't see anything wrong with letting Logan see this movie.
A movie or TV show that relies on violence, sex, nudity and swearing to carry the story or sell tickets is, in my opinion, not worth wasting my time watching.
As to the original question posed in this thread: I agree with Jack. Most sequels and re-makes are a waste. Unless RDA, Henry Winkler and some of the original writers from seasons 3-6 were involved, I wouldn't want a MacGyver re-make. Sometimes, with original concepts such as MacGyver, there is no improvement to be made. In these cases, the original stands on its own, a diamond gleaming in the mud. And MacGyver was, is and always will be a gem.
Imagination is more important than knowledge. Albert Einstein
The stuff is already here, I just find a different way to use it. MacGyver
The scary part of it all is that the guys didn't see anything wrong with letting Logan see this movie.
And thats the real problem right there.. bad, or in most cases these days, non-existent parenting.
We've gotten to a stage now where the new parents of the next generation have been raised with this crap on TV and think it's acceptable to let their young kids watch it.
I've gotten to a stage now where I don't allow my kids to watch TV. They are allowed to have limited time to watch kids shows or some other family show from DVD and occasionally they get to play an old PS1 game. But thats it. New Zealands TV standards are so low they allow "sexually orientated" advertisements to play during kids shows.
This is what happens when you let the clowns run the circus.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
QUOTE
Is that what you call violence? MacGyver must have been quite violent to you then.
No, it doesn't. Everything I like is in it on a pretty low level but it suits in the show.
What do you call violence? Torture?
MacGyver is pretty tame for me. I just find it rousing.
QUOTE
As far as swearing goes, I know we've had this conversation before. Contemporary movies use nudity, swearing and violence as filler and distraction for movies that lack engaging writing and a decent plot.
If it's useful to the plot why not? You can't write an erotic thriller like Fatal Attraction or Basic Instinct without nudity, swearing and violence. And those are near classics in it's genre.
QUOTE
So how can those of us who are parents fight back? The only way the entertainment industry can understand. Do not support entertainment that is not in alignment with your own values. Do not buy, rent, or attend in a theater, movies you find offensive. Do not watch TV shows you find offensive. Monitor and censor what your children view. If you wouldn't take your child to see it in the theater, don't rent it and watch it together at home. If enough people do these things, and demand suitable entertainment, then things will change. My biggest fear is that we are too late and that most people are too numbed and dumbed by the trivial crap served as entertainment to care or to take action.
Do you really think they would care? I've heard from more than one director that if you're shocked by materials in the film like nudity, violence or swearing, you shouldn't watch it. Than they would just make it for the ones who can handle it. I wonder what happens when the new generation fully takes over. PG-13's will not work out. In the action genre it's debatable but if it was meant for R ratings, they shouldn't make it PG-13. PG-13 horrorflicks are a complete disaster, those are certainly not working out. If horrorflicks like Saw, Hellraiser, Halloween and other demonic creatures becomes PG-13 those franchises are over.
When I'm talking to you guys here it's like I'm talking to my mother about it. The swearing doesn't bother her to much but the nudity and torture does. I don't understand why. Either show it because it adds up to the movie or don't show it at all. We discussed this with Christmas eve and my grandfather explained it's the generation gap.
Now it feels like it's me against you all. This probably meaning I'm the youngest here and the only of the latest generation.
QUOTE
I have a strict policy on the types of movies and TV shows I let my 4 year old watch. I came home one afternoon and my husband, nephew, his girlfriend and my brother-in-law were all watching Casino Royale, with my 4 year old son. You're right MG that this movie doesn't have a lot of swearing, however it is extremely violent and completely uinsuitable for a child. To say that I pitched a coniption fit would be an understatement. The scary part of it all is that the guys didn't see anything wrong with letting Logan see this movie.
OK, 4 years old is even in my opinion way too young to watch Casino Royale. I think I was only six at the time when I first watched Lethal Weapon 3. Casino Royale was the Die Hard of 2006 for me it's indeed violent. There are at least like 5 fights in it. Your guys probably figured, there's no swearing in it so it's alright for him.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)