This is something which has been in my mind for the last couple of days, and I wonder if anyone else has thought about it?
There seems to be somewhat of a paradox between MacGyver’s acceptance of the supernatural and the overall characteristic of MacGyver being open to new ideas and such.
One of the fairly strong characteristics of MacGyver is that he is open to new ideas, different ways of thinking, accepting of all, etc. Unless, it would seem, that idea is something to do with the supernatural. In which case he immediately dismisses it, as witnessed in The Secret of Parker House when he tells Penny “the supernatural is just a way of explaining stuff science hasn’t figured out yet” and in The Visitor episode when he says something like he prefers to take a scientific view of things.
But the paradox runs even deeper. Because then we have, in the very same episodes in which he dismisses the supernatural, an indication at the end that he accepts it. For example, in The Secret of Parker House, when the sheriff is killed, it’s indicated that there may have been supernatural forces there, without any protest from MacGyver about it. This same thing happens at the end of The Visitor, and we can even go back to Ghost ship with the Bigfoot howling at the end, or indeed The Madonna. These all have some form of Supernatural play in them, which at some level is dismissed by MacGyver and then accepted.
Now I realize that these are only meant as entertaining little twists at the end of the stories, but it is an interesting little paradox created by the writers for the sake of entertainment, and something to lay awake thinking about at night.
It could probably also be argued that this paradox is quite realistic, after all, how many people can claim to believe 100% in supernatural 100% of the time? For most people it’s a pretty much grey area, with your perceptions depending on the evidence available for each case. Some ghost stories have an obvious explanation, while others give you cause to stop and think. So in this way I guess the MacGyver/supernatural paradox could be quite realistic in that he doesn’t want to believe, but sometimes just can’t help it.
Posts: 524
Joined: 3 May 2005
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Superchamp
Favorites
Season: season 4
Episode:Too many to choose from
Vehicle: Nomad
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
Hmm. Interesting observation, Rocky. I've noticed it, too. I guess the best explanation is that Mac is a very practical and scientific sort of person, and scientific types often have a hard time accepting things for which there isn't much solid evidence. (This is why, for example, most scientists are atheists or at least hard-core agnostics.) You do have to bear in mind the scientific method here: form a hypothesis, gather evidence, design an experiment, look at your results, draw a conclusion based on the evidence and your results.
As for the end of Secret of Parker House, plus Ghost Ship, maybe it was to show that Mac did get challenged in his thinking. Looks like it didn't have much immediate effect, but who knows what might have happened in the long run?
Also, it could have been just a device to make the character more believable... we all have contradictions like that in our personalities, and that was one of Mac's quirks.
Do not pity the dead. Pity the living, and above all, those who live without love. Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
You don't eat things like that, you call pest control! Kate in The Gauntlet
What's that? Lateral... cranial... impact... enhancer. *whack* Last Stand
Yeah I don't actually think it was intentionally done by the writers. I think these things where just written together from an entertainment aspect but when you put them all together, they form this unintentional paradox.
Posts: 2,949
Joined: 11 Nov 2006
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Interesting question.
I think that MacGyver dismisses the supernatural initially since he is a man of logic and science. He accepts the supernatural as a possible explanation only after science and logic have failed to completely explain, to his satisfaction, the situation. He then considers the possibility that there are forces in the universe that operate off the radar of science and logic. When the possibility that the supernatural may play a role in the events he's involved in, MacGyver opens up to it.
I don't think he truly accepts the supernatural as the only explanation to an unknown, but rather that unexplained forces have a supporting role in the explanation.
Supernatural forces are generally dismissed by people, especially in this modern technological age, however, the anecdotal evidence of such forces is too prevelant to be completely ignored. From personal experience, I have seen things in the desert night sky that give you one of these what the.......moments.
A few years ago, I was camping in southern Utah, around Escalante, with some friends. I was having one of my bouts of insommnia and got out of the tent in the middle of the night. It was mega dark, only starlight, no moon. I was sitting on a rock staring up at the sky and I saw this really strange light. It was green, but not like the kind you would see on airplane wings and there was no red light like with airplanes. It pulsed, getting very bright and then very faint, almost fading away before flaring again. It stayed in one spot for quite a while. I could tell because I marked its position against a rock formation and the closest star against the same rock formation. The position of the star changed, but the light didn't.
I watched it for almost 2 hours when it suddenly flared very bright and then streaked off across the night sky heading straight south. It was not like anything I have ever seen. I know it wasn't light pollution from a city. The closest town is Escalante and it isn't big enough to create light pollution. I don't think it was an airplane since the lights were different and it remained stationary for 2 hours. I don't think it was a helicopter since I couldn't hear the characteristic sounds of the engine rotors and again the lights were different. It could have been an experimental military aircraft, but the nearest possible landing strips are quite a far distance from Escalante. To this day, I still wonder what it might be.
I'm open to the possibilities that it might be something more than the simple logical scientific explanation. I wasn't drinking or under the influence of any medication that induces hallucinations. Like MacGyver says at the end of the Visitor..........."you gotta wonder."
So that's my experience. I have a few others but its somebody else's turn. So who else has had an unexplained encounter with a supernatural event?
Imagination is more important than knowledge. Albert Einstein
The stuff is already here, I just find a different way to use it. MacGyver
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
QUOTE (MacGirl @ 1 February 2008 - 03:49 PM)
(This is why, for example, most scientists are atheists or at least hard-core agnostics.)
Actually, they aren't; but it's a very common misconception, because scientists don't often talk about their personal beliefs. The ones that do talk are the ones that tend to be atheists or agnostics, but they don't represent the majority any more than the overly vocal fringe of most groups.
To be a scientist at all requires a strong streak of idealism, after all . . . and idealism is a kind of faith, or at least closely akin to it.
Just as someone who works with computers knows their limitations, most scientists have a keen sense of what aspects of life can be best addressed by science, and what aspects fall outside.
Most scientists are moderate in their beliefs, but they do have them. By the same token, most scientists fall in love, have hobbies they're passionate about, have kids and find them infuriating and love them all the same -- none of which is purely rational.
However, at the same time, scientists tend not to be intensely superstitious, and they're less likely to believe in the supernatural. Unlike personal spirituality -- which is generally held apart from the urge to test for scientific plausibility -- supernatural phenomena are often held up for testing, and usually fail. Moreover, the methods of testing are usually badly thought out and applied in a biased manner, which ticks off scientists faster than just about anything else, including gratuitous stupidity (or their kids).
My own father was quiet in his faith, passionately outspoken in his idealism, had little time for superstition or the supernatural, and quickly became impatient and dismissive of pseudoscience . . . as well as politics, bureaucratic obstructionism, and bad journalism.
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: Observatory
I think MacGyver tries to be all things to all people as much as possible and I think he's at least open to considering the supernatural. Though I would agree that it's probably not going to be the first option if there's another reasonable, logical explanation that can be found first. And I don't think most scientists are necessarily atheists or agnostics. Of course, I'm sure there are certainly some who are such- but then there's also scientists who are Christians (and Christian Scientists- but that's something else altogether ) - and of different religions. But I think there should also be a bit of a distinction made on this point. I think most of the "supernatural" things (at least the ones shown on MacGyver- Bigfoot, ghosts, UFOs) fall into a separate category from religion and faith. (At least it does in the Dewey Decimal system.) Whereas you might believe in some supernatural things - (i.e. God, angels, the devil, demons) - you may not believe in others (i.e. Sasquatch, aliens, werewolves, etc.) But I like that MacGyver is willing to at least consider the possibilities. "You gotta wonder"... I suppose it might create something of a paradox, but I doubt that's really intentional. It might be with Kolchak, the Night Stalker (though actually, I think he pretty much believed in everything) or Indiana Jones (he was more of the skeptic who had to be convinced with signs and wonders first) With MacGyver, I think they were just there mainly for entertainment and to give the ending a little twist.
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)