If they have any one of the original actors, then they need ALL of the original actors (assuming they plan to use those characters.) In other words, if they bring back Bruce McGill, they can't then have someone other than RDA playing Mac. Same thing with RDA-- if they bring him back, they can't have someone other than Bruce playing Jack, or Michael playing Murdoc. There has to be a consistancy-- either bring back the original actors, or don't. But don't do half/half.
The other thing is, I see no point in replacing the original actors with other actors who are just as old. Some people are suggesting actors who are as old as Bruce and Rick, and that's perfectly fine for this poll since we're all just having fun, but as far as an actual movie is concerned, the only reason they should replace actors is if they want to go back in time and set the show in a period when the characters are younger. Just my feelings on it.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Good point.
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
How about David Cursoe (Horatio Cane CSI Miami) has Murdoc. He has the red hair. I don't really know about the behavior. How about Sean P Diddy Combs as one of the Coltons along with Arzenio Hall (sorry about the spelling).
Was Nikki really an important part of the show? I guess I would rather see someone like Deborah, Kate, Zoe, or Mike that had some impact on Mac's life. Nikki appeared to rub Pete and Mac the wrong way. Just my opinion.
I think she was more of a thorn in his side. I know he liked her as a friend. But what did she do for him? The way I see it he did more for her then she did for him. Where was she when Pete and Mac were reminising about the "old days" before Pete's eye surgery? She just annoyed me. Mike had more of an impact on Mac's life.
She just annoyed me. Mike had more of an impact on Mac's life.
Mike.. lets see.. Mac had to save her bacon the first time we met her and then the second time she caused him a whole episode on angst by falling off the side of a cliff she was supposed to be guiding him up. (2 episodes)
Deborah suckered MacGyver into falling in love with her and then tried to kill him. Then came back and tried to kill him a second time (2 episodes)
Kate What did Kate ever do for MacGyver? (3 episodes?)
Zoe Set his houseboat out to sea and forced him into an adventure he didn't want any part of. (1 episode)
Nikki worked with MacGyver to capture the diplomat in fire and ice, Tried to help him out of his slump in Widow maker, tracked him down in the mountains to tell him about Starkos in GX-1, Challenged MacGyver's ideas and way of thinking, but ended up being useful (I think?) in Blowout. challenged MacGyver head-on about her boy-friend in Early retirement Helped Pete try to contact MacGyver once they realized Deborah was a killer in The Negotiator. Became a good and trusted friend even though she was head strong and stubborn. (6 episodes)
I think Nikki is more worthy of a role in a movie than any of the afore mentioned females.
I think Nikki is more worthy of a role in a movie than any of the afore mentioned females.
I agree. While Penny Parker attached to Mac on his personal life, Nikki is on the professional side. I always want to have more Nikki in the show and feel sorry for her disappearance after The Negotiator.
Nikki worked with MacGyver to capture the diplomat in fire and ice, Tried to help him out of his slump in Widow maker, tracked him down in the mountains to tell him about Starkos in GX-1, Challenged MacGyver's ideas and way of thinking, but ended up being useful (I think?) in Blowout. challenged MacGyver head-on about her boy-friend in Early retirement Helped Pete try to contact MacGyver once they realized Deborah was a killer in The Negotiator. Became a good and trusted friend even though she was head strong and stubborn. (6 episodes)
I think Nikki is more worthy of a role in a movie than any of the afore mentioned females.
Then how come Nikki is never mentioned again after the season she appeared on? It was like she disappeared off of the face of the earth. Nobody mentioned her. Not Mac or Pete so what happened to her?
Posts: 7,214
Joined: 3 Dec 2005
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Camper&Swissbit
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I like Nikki. So many fans angsted and argued about her, protesting the idea of her as a 'love interest' for MacGyver... but she wasn't particularly interested in him, as far as I could see. They fought like cats and dogs, butted heads constantly... but trusted one another and became good friends--the kind of friends who aren't afraid to tell each other that they think that they're full of it.
I'm not sure I understand the resistance about Nikki. I supposed everyone has their own preferences and prejudices regarding Mac's Girls--my own abborance for Maria being most monumental --but facts is facts: Nikki was part of Team Phoenix. I'd vote yea to bring her back.
Everyone, sometimes, needs a camel.
Old troubleshooters never die... They just wait til the last moment and then rescue themselves!
How about Mel Gibson? I can see him either playing Mac or Murdoc. or Kevin Costner. I was watching Bones last night and could see the actor who playes Booth playing Mac. Just a thought
Then how come Nikki is never mentioned again after the season she appeared on? It was like she disappeared off of the face of the earth. Nobody mentioned her. Not Mac or Pete so what happened to her?
That would be because Nikki was originally brought in to be a love interest to MacGyver, which drew such a strong reaction from the female audience, that they had to can the whole idea.
Thats why in GX-1 Starkos tells MacGyver he will grow to love Nikki. They where probably looking to counter the Moonlighting show with a tense relationship. I'm kinda glad they didn't actually, one moonlighting was enough. But I wish they would have kept Nikki around just as a co-worker.
I don't think any of the other females where ever mentioned after their last appearance either were they?
I like Nikki she just irritated me. I guess because she was the female version of Mac. One MacGyver male or female (preferably male) is enough for me. At least Nikki could carry her own weight. I don't know if they were or not. I know Jack got mentioned quiet alot. Speaking of Moonlighting next thing you know they will be making a feature movie of that. I saw a picture of Dennis Leary from Rescue Me. He looks remarkably like RDA. Wonder how he would do as Mac or even as Murdoc?
I saw a picture of Dennis Leary from Rescue Me. He looks remarkably like RDA. Wonder how he would do as Mac or even as Murdoc?
That dude always reminds me of William DaFoe.
Dennis Leary
William DaFoe
I don't think he has the right personality to play MacGyver actually. In the couple of interviews I've seen him in (as well as the shows he appears in) he seems much more "adult orientated" almost sleazy to a certain degree.
I wouldn't mind seeing him play Murdoc though. Or even William DaFoe himself playing Murdoc.
Posts: 7,777
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Country: Belgium
SAK owned: Don't know
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Passages, Humanity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
If you have ever seen Judgment Night, Dennis Leary might be up for the job to play Murdoc. He can play a real villain and his role in Judgment Night is a great example for it. He played it real cold but cool and very very determined. Not a guy you want to be messing with and certainly not someone you wanna bump into in a dark alley. His rule nr. 2 in the movie was: 'No witnesses.' and he meant it and he would go after you until you're dead. Guess he wanted to be 'quick, neat and untraceable' too.
Willem Dafoe is about the same thing though I think he's more relaxed in playing the role.
Problem with the both of em is they got blue eyes. Maybe not such a problem but what do you prefer? Ice cold blue eyes or Murdoc's dark evil eyes?
I think the poison that was used was applied to this knife, passed to the mutton when it was cut and then activated by the wine. - MacGyver. Sometimes you just have to die a little inside to be reborn and rise again as a stronger and wiser version of you. It's better to be a little sad than to be fake content.
Penny Parker - Melissa Fitzgerald or Sandra Bullock
Nikki Carpenter - Patricia Richardson
Wow. that was a lot harder than I thought it was gonna be.. especially the female roles... I'm not a big TV watcher and my brain went completely blank.
You know Rocky, I can totally see Kevin Bacon playing MacGyver. I guess it has something to do with the jaw line.
I saw a picture of Dennis Leary from Rescue Me. He looks remarkably like RDA. Wonder how he would do as Mac or even as Murdoc?
That dude always reminds me of William DaFoe.
I don't think he has the right personality to play MacGyver actually. In the couple of interviews I've seen him in (as well as the shows he appears in) he seems much more "adult orientated" almost sleazy to a certain degree.
I wouldn't mind seeing him play Murdoc though. Or even William DaFoe himself playing Murdoc.
Actually Dennis Leary gives me the creeps. I don't even know why I said him. You know we are never going to agree on who can play any of the characters from the series. Tim Allen would make a good Jack Dalton.
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:Good Knight Macgyver
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: Loft
QUOTE (Murdoc12 @ 18 March 2009 - 06:50 AM)
Murdoc-Ozzie Osbourne
**run away screaming** Ozzie's a little too creepy for me. Someone suggested Jim Carey though; I think he's just creepy enough to do it without scary somebody.
I also could see the guy who plays Booth on Bones as Mac. He kinda has that way about him.
Duct Tape: it has a light side and a dark side and it holds the world together.
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Passages
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I have to agree with Aussie on this one. When I watch Bruce McGill on Rizzoli & Isles I see him as only Jack. Same thing when he was in Legally Blonde 2.
I'm with Aussie too - there have been some absolute trainwrecks in recent years made in the name of re-vamping classic films and/or series. I'm thinking particularly of Starsky and Hutch and The Professionals here....
That's not to say there haven't been some good ones too, just that the potential for creating a stinker is really very high!
Posts: 903
Joined: 7 May 2010
Gender: Male
Country: CO
SAK owned: Spartan
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode: . . . Holy Rose
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I think that with certain characters, unless we're talking about a younger version, they should not be re-cast . . . EVER . . . for any reason.
RDA is MacGyver Tom Selleck is Magnum Harrison Ford is Han Solo and Indiana Jones etc., etc., etc.
Rather than trying to capitalize on something that has already been done, very well in the case of MacGyver, I say be creative and come up with something new.
"Jeep. My Jeep? What are you talking about? Penny! My Jeep?" - MacGyver
"Look at me. I'm a hurtin' guy! I'm beat up. I need a month's worth of sleep . . . and I need a haircut!" - MacGyver
"It's been said, 'The best gift a man could ever give another, was his life', Jack Dalton was never one to settle for less than the best. Thank you Jack." - MacGyver
"Reboots are born out of the lack of imagination." M. Lance Frank
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Passages, Nightmares
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
QUOTE (Rocket @ 6 May 2013 - 11:35 AM)
I'm with Aussie too - there have been some absolute trainwrecks in recent years made in the name of re-vamping classic films and/or series. I'm thinking particularly of Starsky and Hutch and The Professionals here....
That's not to say there haven't been some good ones too, just that the potential for creating a stinker is really very high!
I totally agree! Oh my geese, did you see what they're doing to the Lone Ranger!? D: It's terrible!
"Our principles are the springs of our actions. Our actions, the springs of our happiness or misery. Too much care, therefore, cannot be taken in forming our principles." -Red Skelton
"You can't live in the past - there's a future to be had!"