Depends if he had finished with it or not.
It's common courtesy to return something in a timely manor once your finished with it, but expecting it back the minute it's finished with is a little extreme in most cases; The next day would be fine usually, unless you specifically needed it for something or asked it to be returned that same day when you loaned it out.
To be honest I don't think I would loan out my SAK. To me a SAK is like a wrist watch. It's a personal utility item for me to use.
that's not to say I wouldn't hand it over to someone if I was helping do something with them and they needed to cut or unscrew something, but that's different because I'm standing there with them and would put my hand out to take it back as soon as they had finished with it.
"I want that knife back you know!"