Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Just a few days ago I started to rewatch MacGyver from scratch. So first the Pilot and so on. Now I always look at people's hands, and I think Mac has beautiful, expressive hands. Which is a bonus in a series in which the leading character works a lot with his hands, in close up. All the more irritating to see other hands than Mac's being used as the series evolves. The first scene I believe that a hand double is used is in Hellfire – when MacGyver fixes the car with a ballpoint pen. I looked at the hands in close up and they didn't look at all like the real ones. Now I wonder: how many of those hand doubles are used in the series?
So here's an idea: why don't we all try to collect all those hand double scenes?
I haven't read all the other topics yet, so if this has already been done, forget it. If not, let the game begin!
Another 'hands' observation, but I don't know to which topic this belongs: I've seen several scenes in which Mac in a medium shot uses one hand and in the next shot in close up we see the other hand. First I saw that in Trumbo's World, later in other episodes. It would be fun to collect those scenes, too. Anybody?
I don't think the hell fire scene is a hand double, but rather a seperate shot filmed probably at a different time. The reason the hands look different is because the close up shot has nice clean hands, the medium shot has dirty hands covered in oil and dirt.
And I think you'll find the other scenes you mentioned aren't so much hand doubles as editing errors. Using scenes from different takes (where filming has continued the next day, for example).
The reversal of hands could also be an error in film processing where the image is reversed. I don't entirely understand this photographic process, but I've seen it in both printed media as well as TV/film. Printed media (magazines etc) will often print the image backwards (left is right - right is left) and recently I've seen this on TV shows, most recently the new Knight Rider show has a scene where the image is flipped, so I'd be interested to know the exact scene you talking about so I could take a look at it myself.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Jeepers, you're taking all the fun out of the game before it even started. Joke. Discussion is nice, and also part of the game. And yes, in Hellfire the close-up of the hands is shot at another time, but the hands are clearly different hands, with blunt fingernails. Mac's are long - I read a comment on YouTube that said: the guy even has the most beautiful fingernails in the world. LOL.
As to the shot I referred to in Trumbo's world, it is not reversed so that the left hand becomes the right hand. The medium shot shows Mac with his right hand on the map. The insert shows the map clearly in the same position, but with the left hand.
A very clear example is to be found in The Enemy Within. When Mac meets his fellow spy in the woods he catches the cartridge with his right hand, in the next shot he has the cartridge in his left hand. A nice continuity mistake. I love to detect that kind of stuff and I still hope more people want to play..
Yeah what your talking about is continuity between different takes. Where they have to do several takes of the same scene and then in the editing room they have to mix and match various parts of the different shots together to get a full scene.
It's an unfortunate side effect of having an 8 day dead-line to complete an episode. Little things like which arm someone was leaning on in the last take or which hand was in front of the other simply get over looked because they have top complete the scenes scheduled for that day.
The Hellfire scene may well have been filmed by the second film unit and used a stand in while RDA was out working with the primary film unit. It would actually make sense too, simply because they have to use 2 filming units to get all the filming done in time. Unit 1 does all the main stuff with RDA and unit 2 films the scenes that don't require RDA, or use doubles/stand ins.
It would be interesting to get a list of these scenes where things don't quite match up.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Yeah. Those thumbs are a dead giveaway, too. If you don' see them, you're looking at a hand double.
Speaking of which. I found two more hand double scenes. Well, actually, I'm not 100% certain about the first: the one in Slow Death where Mac rigs the electrical panel in the locomotive.
On the other hand <g>, The Escape offers plenty of hand double moments: first when Mac fixes Khan's radio, and later on when he makes a pcp bomb.
This is something I've never even thought about until you started this topic. And there seems to be a trend emerging already that they re-filmed close up parts of MacGyverisms.
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
Oh, dearie me. Another excuse, I mean reason, to go re-watch episodes.
Actually, it's my impression that they used hand doubles as rarely as possible -- far less often than would have been usual. Normally, the lead is on such a tight shooting schedule that the second unit is better off using a double. But RDA's hands are so distinctive, they couldn't get away with it easily, and only rarely tried.
*off to watch more episodes*
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Sorry, 'Beth, for burdening you with all that extra work. It's a chore, I know. Hopefully it won't keep you from writing..
And here's another one. You can't miss it. It's in Final Approach, the scene where Mac picks up a big rock to make a shower for the mountain lion. First you see him with his jacket on, long sleeved, the next shot you see two bare arms and hands that pick up the rock. Very distinctly not RDA's arms and hands. Next shot, Mac has his arms covered again.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I forgot to mention why I think the arms are bare: because RDA was elsewhere with the jacket on, and they had to improvise.
You know, I would love to read a story titled 'I was RDA's hand double', about a man who wanted to be an actor, but ended up doing this, and even more tragically, never got to meet the star himself, because he was only needed when the star was somewhere else.
Hey 'Beth, Lothi, can't you write me a story like that?
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
It would be kind of a downer as stories go . . . hard to think of a happy ending.
I ran across a comment on another site, about hand doubles -- mentioning that they were used a lot more frequently in Stargate, and you could tell becuase of the unique thumbs.
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
LOL -- maybe you should write it!
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
Still working on Peru -- I had to send a slew of research questions out to my Amazing and Wonderful Stunt Researchers. The results are in, and I'm back at work again.
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
That's great news!
In the meantime another dh scene: in Lost Love part 2 Mac picks a lock with handcuffs. It is hard to see because it's over before you can say 'Go, Mac, go!', but I just can't believe that those hands belong to RDA (especially the thumbs!). Earlier on I had my doubts about another scene, but am not sure.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Nice pictures, Rock.
Last night I saw an another example of the continuity 'hand' thing I talked about earlier: the switching of hands. In Ghost Ship, Mac touches the girl's cheek with his right hand, and in the next take it's his left.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
After having watched a handful of Mac-episodes did I realize I hadn't paid attention to possible hand double scenes. I got so immersed in the stories that I forgot. So I did some fast rewinding and found these: Blow Out , when Mac holds the dynamite wire; The Secret of Parker House, when he puts his hand on the basement wall before blowing it up; Deadly Dreams: when he uses the device to blow up steel doors; when he's going through the library books. Possibly a hand double is used when Mac turns the plastic book cover into a cup – but I'm not sure.
Another thing: I had hoped other members would also come up with some scenes, or tell me that I'm mistaken. Some discussion would have been nice, but it's okay, I'm having enough fun as it is.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Actually, I am not 100% sure. Let's say 90. Look at the fingers. RDA has long slender fingers. These are not. In many cases it will remain guesswork. It would be nice if a producer or director would talk about it.
Posts: 7,214
Joined: 3 Dec 2005
Gender: Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: Camper&Swissbit
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
I wonder if it is something to do with camera angle or technique. The shape of the thumbs is almost right... but foreshortened. And the jacket cuffs are low, like he's hunched or maybe his arms are too short. lol
He's a couple of gratuitous hand-shots that I like. Pretty sure they're the Genuine Article: ... from 'Gold Rush'
Everyone, sometimes, needs a camel.
Old troubleshooters never die... They just wait til the last moment and then rescue themselves!
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
For what it's worth, I've sometimes seen pictures of RDA in which the picture shows his face as well (so no chance of hand doubles), and the fingers look (relatively) short. At some angles, there can be a degree of foreshortening that looks quite startling, particularly on the index finger.
I've also seen some shots where I think his hands were swollen. (He did bang them up a lot.)
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode: must I choose?
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
QUOTE (Traveller)
After having watched a handful of Mac-episodes did I realize I hadn't paid attention to possible hand double scenes. I got so immersed in the stories that I forgot.
Funnily enough, I tend to have the same problem! It's left me without much to contribute to the discussion, so far at least.
[No wilderness] is so dangerous as a city home "with all the modern improvements". One should go to the woods for safety, if for nothing else. -- John Muir --- LOLMac daily: lolmac.livejournal.com icanhastofu.tumblr.com
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Yeah, it's a real problem, so I'll have to re-rewatch several episodes. Maybe even re-re-re-re-watch...
In the meantime, some freshly spotted hand double moments:
In The Black Corsage, when Mac is picking the lock in the amusement park; In Cease Fire, when he is fixing the spark plug; In Unfinished Business, I'm pretty sure the hand that holds Pete's watch is not Mac's (but there is some doubt); In The Legend of the Holy Rose, I've looked again and again at the hands that put Ambrose's mirror in place on the baptismal font, and to me they don't look like MacGyver's hands. Fingers are not long and slender enough.
Sometimes it is very clear, sometimes not. But I'll continue my search, it's fun.
I have been wondering if RDA's stunman Steve Blalock also took care of the hand double scenes. A close-up of his hands would be nice. Maybe someone has a good picture?
Favorites
Season: season 1
Episode:Almost all of them
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black leather
House: House boat
I noticed that difference too I do not remember exactly where, I think it was Prometheus Syndrome. The hands you can see while defusing the bomb are not Mac's. The fingers are thicker. I thought that no-one paid attention at that and suddenly I found the whole thread about this topic
The best way to beat the problem, is to make it work for you
Posts: 59
Joined: 12 Mar 2010
Gender: Male
Country: USA
SAK owned: Climber
Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Thief of Budapest.
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Black/Navy flight
House: House boat
Mac always had very distinctive hands- easy to tell when they're doubled. I want to say Out In The Cold has a few double shots. Have to check that episode again.
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Big Fat Hand Double Shot: at the end of 'Serenity', when Mac holds the old handmade Swiss knife in his hands.
There were some more, but not so obvious, like in 'Live and Learn' (when Mac makes the liquid tp soften the burnt paper); in 'The Treasure of Manco', when Mac holds the headpiece – I almost wrote 'handpiece' .
Earlier on, in the fourth season, I even thought I spotted a 'thumb double' when MacGyver performs the trick with the wax and thumb print, but got confused, because the shape of the thumb is RDA-like, but the nail isn't. Gah, what am I doing?
Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Widowmaker
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Traveller - I have got to give you credit for watching all of these shows and being able to focus enough on the hands. I start watching the shows and next thing you know, I'm focused on the plot, RDA's eyes , or the facial expressions of the actors. I love RDA's hands, but I can never stay focused long enough.
It's a lot of fun to see where you find the hand doubles though. Keep up the good work.
“Typical. Just when you're getting ahead, someone changes the odds." - MacGyver
Posts: 808
Joined: 26 Dec 2009
Gender: ---
Country: Somewhere else
SAK owned: Explorer
Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:Trail of Tears
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket: Brown bomber
House: House boat
Oh, but I have exactly the same problem, Geekgirl (and thanks by the way). It happens to me all the time, that after having watched an episode, I realize I forgot to look for hand double shots. So I'll have to watch it all over again. It's hard. Very hard;-)) But I promised myself to finish the 'job', so I will. Once I spotted the first hand double shot in Hell Fire, I was curious to see if there were more. I'm sure I've missed some, distracted as I get by the plots and all.
And when this is done I want to do some stunt double spotting. Can't help it. It's that dang curiosity of mine.
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)