SGU canned
  Reply to this topic Start new topic Start Poll
Track this topic | Email this topic | Print this topic
Beachbead
Posted: 11 January 2011 - 01:08 PM                                    
Quote Post


Unregistered




Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



Syfy cancels Stargate Universe: Is this the end of the Stargate Franchise?

I'm hopeing the show goes to another network, maybe back to showtime and rethink the show, how to imporve the show and make the necessary changes that made the show what it was when it was SG-1.



 
                                                                     
Top
MacGyverOnline
Posted: 11 January 2011 - 04:52 PM                                    
Quote Post


Administrator
*********

Posts: 9,373
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:   ---
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: ---
Jacket:  ---
House:  ---



I think it was doomed from the start. I watched the show a few times and then gave up on it.

It was really pretty far removed from what we know as StarGate... more like calling Indiana Jones 4 Star Wars because it has Harrison Ford and some space ships in it.





Join the MacGyver Online Network

Facebook ~ X ~ Instagram

 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Bandersnatch
Posted: 12 January 2011 - 08:36 AM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 144
Joined: 23 May 2005
Gender:  Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: A sharp one

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Trail to Doomsday (Movie)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black leather
House:  House boat



Stargate Universe was just a show never meant to be. I know there was a small fan base, but any show will always have a handful of followers. I don't know if it was released at the wrong time, had the wrong group of actors, or just had weak writing -- it just felt too much outside of the Stargate realm fans have known and loved. What little I saw (and I only watched RDA's cameos) looked like a space soap opera, full of darkness, tight shots, and lots of whispering behind backs.

I was never a big fan of SG Atlantis, either, but I did enjoy the few shows I watched. (I'm an RDA fan, not a sci-fi fan, so if The Man wasn't around, neither was I). They had some stories that were different and a cast that worked. It's a shame it went away after only 5 seasons, but according to one of SGU's producers (Cooper, if I'm not mistaken) SGU was only a five season ark too.

Will the canning of SGU be the end of the Stargate franchise? Maybe on TV, but I think it still has a lot of potential in other forms -- books, games, movies, comics, more lovely Jack O'Neill Action Figures... ahem.

Personally, and feel free to disagree, I think the franchise started getting top heavy at the end of SG-1's season 8. Maybe even before then. I mean, how many producers and executive producers does a show need? I think RDA and Michael Greenberg jumped ship and pulled Gekko just in time. The quality of the stories went down in season 8 -- with the exception of a few gems -- and the ratings showed it. With so many hands in the pot and creative minds fighting for credit, the show's dynamics just weakened and buckled. When these people moved onto SGU, the same thing happened -- too many people trying to do different things (actually, it kinda sounds like where I work...)

Bottom line, as much as I would like to see the franchise live on (another SG-1 movie would be nice, or at least tell the teased story in some form), it may just not be possible. Be it bad timing or bad production, the fans weren't ready for a new show carrying the SG name -- especially one as radical as SGU.



"What's a "MacGyver" and why does it have a convention?" ~ Bart Simpson

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 12 January 2011 - 09:38 AM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



I never watched any of the Stargate series when they initially aired, so I've just recently been working my way through the DVDs of SG-1. I'm almost done with Season 3 now, and I have the Season 4 discs already waiting for me.

So far, it's a VERY mixed bag. There are some great episodes, and some absolutely cringe-worthy episodes. Season 1, regrettably, had a few too many cringe-worthy episodes. Season 2 got a bit better, and Season 3 is easily the best so far. Looking forward to seeing how Season 4 is.

Oddly enough, my interest in the show was sparked by the fact that RDA was in it, but I'm starting to find him to be one of the annoying elements of the show. How the hell is he the Colonel? He seems more like the annoying kid who tags along, makes stupid comments, and doesn't really contribute anything to the team. Occasionally he has some great lines, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't laugh, but I just can't believe he's in charge of anything, especially since he always has to ask everyone else what to do, and if their answer involves a word longer than 8 letters, he looks completely confused.

I never tried SGU yet. I'll have to check it out on Hulu one day.



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Beachbead
Posted: 12 January 2011 - 10:31 AM                                    
Quote Post


Unregistered




Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



I didn't get into Stargate sg-1 until season 8 or 9, I got into very late into the

show, i didn't warm up to SGA until season 4. and when SGU rolled around it just

wasn't like the other two shows, it felt dark, and the show just wasn't there it felt

lifeless, souless, i didn't like most of the characters expect for one Eli he was the

mix of Sam and Daniel rolled into one. But even then that didn't keep me watching

the show. i soon gave up in mid season one, only to watch it when Jack,Sam

Tealc, or Daniel came on. They used the stones way too much, had sex in the

show when it wasn't there before,alot of things went wrong with the show. Maybe if

they fixed the things that was wrong with it before it really ended maybe, just

maybe the show could of went on to season five.



 
                                                                     
Top
Bandersnatch
Posted: 13 January 2011 - 01:56 AM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 144
Joined: 23 May 2005
Gender:  Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: A sharp one

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Trail to Doomsday (Movie)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black leather
House:  House boat



QUOTE (Miasma @ 12 January 2011 - 09:41 AM)
How the hell is he the Colonel? He seems more like the annoying kid who tags along, makes stupid comments, and doesn't really contribute anything to the team. Occasionally he has some great lines, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't laugh, but I just can't believe he's in charge of anything, especially since he always has to ask everyone else what to do, and if their answer involves a word longer than 8 letters, he looks completely confused.

Actually, this is part of the character's enduring nature. He's not stupid, he knows exactly what he's doing. And RDA added this "thick" quark to his character on purpose. What better way to outsmart your enemy then by getting them to underestimate you. He may not be able to build a nuclear reactor or blow up a sun, but he can lay a trap for the enemy to keep his people safe.

The colonel may not be a genius like Carter or Jackson, but his survival skills help round out the group. A team needs a balance of brains and brawn -- SG-1 has both. A team of all geeks would be gunned down quickly, just as a team of all grunts would be outsmarted. Just because someone doesn't appear to be smart on the outside, doesn't mean they aren't.

Asking his team what to do is just part of "teamwork." He may make the final decision, but he wants to know what his options are first. Military tends to be "if we don't know what it is, let's blow it up." Science tends to be "let's talk to it first." Both methods have their valid points, but it's up to the team leader to decide which is the safest way to go.

And as for Jack's "stupid comments" -- I take offense to this. It's called a dry, cynical sense of humor, and I happen to have one of those myself. If I'm under stress or angry, my comments get more and more sarcastic. It's a copping mechanism. It's used to break up tension, and in some cases to antagonize the person/people creating the stressful situation. Jack's comments aren't stupid or annoying. In fact, they're quite close to what RDA is really like himself.



"What's a "MacGyver" and why does it have a convention?" ~ Bart Simpson

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 13 January 2011 - 03:43 PM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



QUOTE (Bandersnatch @ 13 January 2011 - 01:59 AM)
 

QUOTE

What better way to outsmart your enemy then by getting them to underestimate you.

Ok, but a lot of the time it has nothing to do with outsmarting the enemy. If it was about that, then why does he act stupid when he's just talking to Sam and Daniel? They're not his enemies. There are a few too many times when they discuss a simple concept that the average viewer can understand perfectly well, and O'Neill looks completely befuddled by it.
I THINK part of the purpose in O'Neill being a bit slow-witted is that it's a way to have Sam and Carter slow down and explain things more clearly so that the audience can understand it, and sometimes it works well in that way, but there are a few too many times when what they're talking about isn't complicated enough to confuse anyone. That's when O'Neill's dim-wittedness gets a bit irritating-- we, as the viewers, want the plot to move along, but Sam and Carter have to stop and explain everything again for Jack. Kind of like in school when the slow kid keeps making the teacher repeat something that everyone else understands already.

QUOTE

A team of all geeks would be gunned down quickly, just as a team of all grunts would be outsmarted.

Completely agree with you. But there's something between being a geek and being obtuse. Jack sometimes comes across as a bit obtuse (certainly more obtuse than a colonel should be.) Maybe he gets better in the later seasons. Like I said, I'm only on Season 3.
Also, the "geeks" in this case (Sam and Carter) have proven to be very good in a fight, and they don't get gunned down quickly. That's what makes Jack feel a bit redundant at times-- The team consists of three highly intelligent people who are also good in combat, plus one team leader who's also good in combat, but not particularly intelligent. That makes him the weak link of the group. There are a lot of episodes in which Jack could be removed from the equation, and the team would be no worse off.

QUOTE

And as for Jack's "stupid comments" -- I take offense to this.  It's called a dry, cynical sense of humor, and I happen to have one of those myself.

Making jokes is fine. Contributing nothing to a situation while making jokes (while your coworkers try to actually solve the problem) can get a bit annoying.

Having said all that, I don't hate the character. Like I said before, I do get a laugh from him. I just don't believe him as a team leader. I haven't yet seen him demonstrate any skillset that makes him more qualified than the other people on his team. Quite the opposite, in fact.

I strongly suspect one of the reasons he acts the way he does is to help ground the show. He's kind of the "everyman" that we're supposed to relate to. He rolls his eyes when we roll our eyes. He makes the quips that we're thinking. He keeps things from getting too serious. Etc, etc. And that's good. But I feel like it might have been more believable if he had a different rank.



 
PM                                                                     
Top
MacGyverOnline
Posted: 13 January 2011 - 06:02 PM                                    
Quote Post


Administrator
*********

Posts: 9,373
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:   ---
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: ---
Jacket:  ---
House:  ---



Your watching a show about people traveling to other worlds in other galaxies and fighting aliens and your biggest complaint is that the Colonel rank isn't believable??



Join the MacGyver Online Network

Facebook ~ X ~ Instagram

 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 14 January 2011 - 02:19 AM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



QUOTE (Rockatteer @ 13 January 2011 - 06:05 PM)
Your watching a show about people traveling to other worlds in other galaxies and fighting aliens and your biggest complaint is that the Colonel rank isn't believable??

Hmmm... not sure where I said that was my biggest complaint. hmm.bmp

But I know what you mean-- there are a lot of unbelievable things on the show, so why should an unbelievable colonel matter? The difference, for me at least, is that the other unbelievable stuff is all within the realm of sci-fi. It's supposed to be far-fetched and unbelievable. But the basic idea of Jack being the colonel is NOT supposed to be far-fetched/unbelievable (at least I don't think it is.) So it feels more out of place. It's hard to explain, but there's a difference.

Anyway, I plan to watch the season 3 finale tonight, and then I'm about to start seaon 4. Looking forward to it!



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Bandersnatch
Posted: 14 January 2011 - 08:19 AM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 144
Joined: 23 May 2005
Gender:  Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: A sharp one

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Trail to Doomsday (Movie)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black leather
House:  House boat



QUOTE (Miasma @ 13 January 2011 - 03:46 PM)
But I feel like it might have been more believable if he had a different rank.

Well, you'd better brace yourself then. If think colonel is hard to believe, wait until he hits 3-star general.



"What's a "MacGyver" and why does it have a convention?" ~ Bart Simpson

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Beachbead
Posted: 14 January 2011 - 12:46 PM                                    
Quote Post


Unregistered




Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



I like Jack the way he is, people don't expect him to be the way he is, as RDA said there are people who are in the military who are way worse then Jack is.



 
                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 15 January 2011 - 04:42 AM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



I guess it's true that a lot of times the people who are in charge of things are less qualified than their subordinates. Not necessarily in the military, but you hear about it happening a lot in corporations. So maybe RDA was working with that idea.

Anyway, I just watched the Season 3 finale (Nemesis) last night-- great episode, with a good cliff-hanger. I plan to start watching Season 4 this weekend. The show has gotten consistantly better, so my hopes are high.




 
PM                                                                     
Top
MacGyverOnline
Posted: 15 January 2011 - 08:45 AM                                    
Quote Post


Administrator
*********

Posts: 9,373
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:   ---
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: ---
Episode:
Vehicle: ---
Jacket:  ---
House:  ---



QUOTE (Miasma @ 15 January 2011 - 05:45 AM)
So maybe RDA was working with that idea.

Well actually RDA has stated quite a lot that he deliberately dumbed down the character to avoid having to remember all the techno-babble lines that Carter and Jackson got.

*points at head* Up here for thinking. laugh.gif

QUOTE
I guess it's true that a lot of times the people who are in charge of things are less qualified than their subordinates.  Not necessarily in the military, but you hear about it happening a lot in corporations.

I experiance it on a daily basis and have seen it in every company I've ever had to deal with. You can't promote the smart people because they are the ones who do the work. If someones good at something you leave them where they are so they can keep doing what they are good at.

Actually military probably promote based on experience and O'Niell has plenty of that. He's not a rocket scientist, but he's a good military man. He knows weapons and tactics and is combat savvy, so from that point of view he's quite believable as a colonel.





Join the MacGyver Online Network

Facebook ~ X ~ Instagram

 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
 0 Members:
     

 Topic Options Reply to this topicStart new topicStart Poll