Yeah your right MacJackson. And I've actually experienced that situation first hand, where we had a
very highly certified network technician come in to do some work on a server for us, problem was he had zero practical knowledge. All he knew was theory, so when we put him in front of the server he couldn't even work out how to log in to the damn thing and after a week we sent him home with instructions to the company to
never send him to us again and give us someone with practical knowledge.
So yeah there is a big difference between book (theory) smart and practical smart, although Carter seems to at least be able to use her book smarts and apply it to what she's doing.
For the record I think MacGyver is smarter, because he has a broader knowledge base and seems to be able to pick things up really quickly. He also has the ability to apply the knowledge he has in an adaptive way to the situation he's in.. i.e MacGyverisms.
Imaging if Carter and MacGyver got together.