We have had discussions about this in the past and I think the only way we could really judge this is to have a ginormous poll with every episode listed. which I might just do!

In all honesty I'm not sure I have a single favorite episode any more.

There are several I tend to think of when I feel like watching MacGyver, but it kind of depends on my mood to which ones I watch. Sometimes I just have a hankering to watch a particular kind of episode. For example, sometimes I feel like watching an outdoors survival type episode, with lots of trees and greenery in it, other times I feel like watching a city episode, lots of cars, concrete, lights etc.
Having said all that though, if I had to give my favorite episode without thinking, it would probably be lost love (both episodes). That episode kinda epitomizes my whole vision of MacGyver and I think it's also the episode which really drew me in as a full blow fan.