MacGyver vs Stargate SG-1
  Reply to this topic Start new topic Start Poll
Track this topic | Email this topic | Print this topic
Dr Zito
  Posted: 6 October 2011 - 07:57 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



again apologies if this has been made before

whats your favourite of the two shows?

Obviously most people will prefer MG over SG-1 with this being a MG forum and all tongue.gif , but for me Sg-1 was the superior series and I actually like better RDA character, O'neill, than MG himself. Blasphemy I hear you saying! possibly, I still love MG and watch it continuosly then come here to bitch about it biggrin.gif , but while MG for me hasnt aged that well, SG i think will be considered in time as one of the great scifi series of all time

you can punch me right here boxing.gif , but avoid the face, I have a legion of women to satisfy



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
KiwiTek
Posted: 6 October 2011 - 08:18 PM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Special Agent
********

Posts: 4,093
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:  Male
Country: NZ
SAK owned: Tinker

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Runners
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



They're too completely different shows really, each with their own strengths and weaknesses. Hard to compare, for me they are equal, but for completely different reasons.

I agree with your comments, but the ideal of MacGyver is think will far outlive the show itself.

hmm.bmp



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 6 October 2011 - 08:28 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



QUOTE (KiwiTek @ 6 October 2011 - 08:21 PM)
I agree with your comments, but the ideal of MacGyver is think will far outlive the show itself.

hmm.bmp

good point

Someone was saying on another thread that very seldom you get the character of a series to become a part of the daily vocabulary of popular culture, to almost turn into a verb by itself like people use it in spanish (macgiveriando, which means fixing stuff) or to an adjective (to call someone MacGyver because he solves a problem).

also as a series MG was about more than just the action, it taught values and morals that SG-1 never really paid much attention to, being more focused on pure entertainment.



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Bandersnatch
Posted: 7 October 2011 - 02:06 AM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 144
Joined: 23 May 2005
Gender:  Female
Country: USA
SAK owned: A sharp one

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Trail to Doomsday (Movie)
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black leather
House:  House boat



I like them both for different reasons. MacGyver is a great character and very unique to the world of heroes. He's an ordinary, everyday guy that uses his smarts to help make his little piece of the world (or sometimes even the entire world if we want to talk about the nuclear moments) better. He's against violence (yet he does play hockey... hmm.bmp ) but he's not afraid to throw a punch if the bad guy refuses to listen to reason. He's a smart, handsome, resourceful, funny, and very human sort of guy.

I like Jack O'Neill because his personality is along the same lines as my own. Cynical, sarcastic, a little suspicious, cut to the chase sort of sense. We also share a love of the Simpsons. Jack likes his weapons, but he's willing to listen to the voice of reason (Daniel or Sam typically) if it looks like there's another way to do something. He cares for his team, and will do anything to keep them safe. Jack is very smart, funny, handsome, resourceful, and maybe a little more human than Mac, especially when thinking about the two characters in this day and age.

Both shows have their high and low points, but the common thread of RDA is what gives them both a spot in my heart.



"What's a "MacGyver" and why does it have a convention?" ~ Bart Simpson

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Beachbead
Posted: 7 October 2011 - 05:44 AM                                    
Quote Post


Unregistered




Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



I like both shows, there two different shows. one about spys and the other about SCFI other worls stuff.



 
                                                                     
Top
Makedde
Posted: 7 October 2011 - 06:48 PM                                    
Quote Post


DXS Operative
****

Posts: 353
Joined: 6 Mar 2011
Gender:  Female
Country: Aussieland
SAK owned: Spartan

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Hell Week
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



I wonder what would happen if you asked people two questions:

'Who is MacGyver'? and 'Who is Jack O'Neill'. My guess is the person would know instantly who Mac is, but wouldn't have a clue about Jack.

I pick MacGyver. I love both shows but MacGyver I find more interesting.



"You may not believe this, but there have been times when I've had a lot more fun in the back seat of a car." - MacGyver (Golden Triangle)

 
PM                                                                     
Top
KiwiTek
Posted: 7 October 2011 - 07:01 PM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Special Agent
********

Posts: 4,093
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:  Male
Country: NZ
SAK owned: Tinker

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Runners
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



True, but it's not a a very good comparison because SG:1 had 4 main characters, MacGyver only had 1 and he was both the character and the name of the show. For a true comparison you would have to ask if they knew MacGyver & SG:1.




 
PM                                                                     
Top
Makedde
Posted: 8 October 2011 - 04:47 PM                                    
Quote Post


DXS Operative
****

Posts: 353
Joined: 6 Mar 2011
Gender:  Female
Country: Aussieland
SAK owned: Spartan

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Hell Week
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



QUOTE (KiwiTek @ 7 October 2011 - 07:04 PM)
True, but it's not a a very good comparison because SG:1 had 4 main characters, MacGyver only had 1 and he was both the character and the name of the show. For a true comparison you would have to ask if they knew MacGyver & SG:1.

Older folk would know MacGyver because they grew up with it. People a little younger would know Stargate because they grew up with that. It'd depend.



"You may not believe this, but there have been times when I've had a lot more fun in the back seat of a car." - MacGyver (Golden Triangle)

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 8 October 2011 - 08:38 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



to be honest sg-1 seems to me a more adult, sarcastic and rounded up show than MG, and probably it'll stand better the test of time for those very reasons. MG was a family show and had a preachy air about it in many episodes that are part of its charm but also a downfall when it comes to how it stands time. I think if we take alone the two main characters of the shows there can be discussion, which one you prefer if Mac or O'neill, but as quality goes, for me, SG-1 clearly had by far better standards when it came to writing and directing.

Ive been watching a lot of MG episodes recently and much more than its individual episodes what remains great about the show is MG himself, the series though, had many fillers, really mediocre episodes that are surprisingly childish and simplistic. Not to say it doesnt have good episodes, im not saying that at all, still has, but not a very high proportion. I've should add that Im talking mostly about season 1 and 2, which are the ones Ive been watching recently. The others havent since a long time ago.



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
KiwiTek
Posted: 8 October 2011 - 11:03 PM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Special Agent
********

Posts: 4,093
Joined: 29 Nov 2003
Gender:  Male
Country: NZ
SAK owned: Tinker

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:Runners
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



Yeah quality wise, SG-1 wins hands down, but then when I think back to the era that MacGyver was made in, it was probably on par with most shows of the time.

I think a lot of the "bad" was really just poor story lines. Other aspects of production seemed quite good and even ground breaking. MacGyver was the first show to broadcast in the US in stereo and in-fact was recording in stereo long before stereo broadcasts were available. TV went stereo in season 4 but all of season 3 is in stereo on the DVD's because they recorded stereo at time of production.

As far as SG-1 standing the test of time better than MacGyver. I think your right, but mainly because the whole premise and concept of the show is a fairly timeless idea and so the stories it tells will also be timeless. These kinds of sci-fi shows usually last pretty well. Just look at Star Wars.



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 9 October 2011 - 08:07 AM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



QUOTE (KiwiTek @ 8 October 2011 - 11:06 PM)
Yeah quality wise, SG-1 wins hands down, but then when I think back to the era that MacGyver was made in, it was probably on par with most shows of the time.

I think a lot of the "bad" was really just poor story lines. Other aspects of production seemed quite good and even ground breaking. MacGyver was the first show to broadcast in the US in stereo and in-fact was recording in stereo long before stereo broadcasts were available. TV went stereo in season 4 but all of season 3 is in stereo on the DVD's because they recorded stereo at time of production.

As far as SG-1 standing the test of time better than MacGyver. I think your right, but mainly because the whole premise and concept of the show is a fairly timeless idea and so the stories it tells will also be timeless. These kinds of sci-fi shows usually last pretty well. Just look at Star Wars.

yep, agree with most of that. Some of the prime time 80s show really look incredibly dated, I mean things like the A team, dallas are painful to watch today. Compared to those Mac gets A marks. Theres one show though, from the 80s that IMO still remains as one of the best of all time: Wiseguy. The writing on that show.. my god, some of those phrases I still remember, top, top notch

But going back to the topic at hand, Definitely the main difference between the two shows is their target audience. Mac was a show for the entire family, SG-1 aimed at an older demographic and could develop more adult oriented themes. I also think audiences are today far more sophisticated and demanding than in the 80s, but thats a whole different topic. I mean never in Tv we've had show at the same time with the quality of HBO's productions like rome, carnivale, deadwood, the wire, just to name a few, where the writing really aspires to excellence. Its a controversial point but despite all the rose tinted glasses we see through many series of the past , I think there has never been more intelligent tv than today. Theres also never been worst tv, and trashier than today, so basically theres never been so much tv laugh.gif



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Beachbead
Posted: 9 October 2011 - 11:30 AM                                    
Quote Post


Unregistered




Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



Stargate SG-1 and SGA was more to family as well, but when SGU came around it was more for adult's but thats something else all together.



 
                                                                     
Top
MacsLegacyLiveForever
Posted: 11 October 2011 - 10:37 PM                                    
Quote Post


Trouble shooter
**

Posts: 74
Joined: 15 Sep 2011
Gender:  Female
Country: Minnesota, USA
SAK owned: Spartan

Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Eagles, Passages
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



I love both! happy.gif

I think that people think in 'problematic situations' usually at first "What MacGyver would do?" not "What Jack would do?" lol laugh.gif happy.gif



"I guess the way you look at the world depends on where you are. From up here it looked like a pretty nice place."

"When I was a kid, my grandfather used to say to me that ... a fellow's life wasn't worth mentioning if he hadn't shared it with some folks along the way."

"Goodbye, Grandpa."

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Mac Jackson
Posted: 15 October 2011 - 08:24 AM                                    
Quote Post


DXS Operative
****

Posts: 314
Joined: 19 Mar 2009
Gender:  Male
Country: Dickson City PA
SAK owned: Red Swiss

Favorites
Season: season 7
Episode:All when he's on screen.
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



For me, I adore both because of RDA. He's been my idol since MacGyver so anything he's in I'll automatically love. He makes each show. I get to see him react to different moments. I get to see him as a team player and solo. Serious and funny. Sarcastic and...sarcarstic. Anything he touches I love, even if it's for the moments he's on screen:)



Mac Jackson
Host of The MacGyver Podcast and MacGyver/SG-1 Audio Series
iTunes, Stitcher,Facebook and Twitter@macwjackson
Singer/Songwriter of "Harmony Constant"
Songs available on itunes, CDBaby and Amazon
youtube.com/macwjack

 
PMUsers Website                                                                     
Top
MacsLegacyLiveForever
Posted: 19 October 2011 - 12:26 AM                                    
Quote Post


Trouble shooter
**

Posts: 74
Joined: 15 Sep 2011
Gender:  Female
Country: Minnesota, USA
SAK owned: Spartan

Favorites
Season: season 5
Episode:Serenity, Eagles, Passages
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  House boat



QUOTE (Mac Jackson @ 15 October 2011 - 08:27 AM)
For me, I adore both because of RDA. He's been my idol since MacGyver so anything he's in I'll automatically love. He makes each show.

You said it! happy.gif happy.gif



"I guess the way you look at the world depends on where you are. From up here it looked like a pretty nice place."

"When I was a kid, my grandfather used to say to me that ... a fellow's life wasn't worth mentioning if he hadn't shared it with some folks along the way."

"Goodbye, Grandpa."

 
PM                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 20 October 2011 - 03:51 AM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



MacGyver vs SG-1... tough question!

MacGyver was clearly aimed at a much younger audience, so it's a bit hard to judge fairly. When it first aired, I was a kid, so I loved it. I somehow overlooked a lot of the horrible acting and just went with it. Also, while I did find the preachiness of the show a bit irritating, I didn't mind it enough to let it detract from my enjoyment (though I NEVER liked the "cause of the week" episodes, like teaching kids not to drink, etc.)

Now that I'm older, obviously different things appeal to me, and it amazes me how many episodes of the show are cringe-worthy. A lot of it has to do with the acting. RDA is mostly okay (well, even he's pretty bad in the early episodes), but many of the guest stars are just awful, and I know it's practically blasphemy to say this, but I just don't think Dana Elcar was a very good actor. Whenever he tries to look really distressed or concerned about something, it feels fake to me. There are still some episodes I genuinely enjoy, but the ratio of "good" episodes to "mediocre/bad" episodes isn't great. Most of my enjoyment now comes from nostalgia, and also from laughing at the campiness of the show (some episodes fall into the "so bad, they're good" category now.)

SG-1 started out pretty bad and really campy. The first couple of seasons had some truly awful episodes, but I'm now almost finished with season 4, and it's definitely gotten MUCH better. It's aimed at an older audience than MacGyver was, so naturally it appeals more to me now than Mac does. But I don't know if that makes it a better show overall... it's hard to compare shows that are in different genres and aimed at different demographics. Certainly the production values on SG-1 are way better than they were on MacGyver, and most of the guest stars put in better performances. I also prefer Don S Davis' acting over Dana Elcar's-- he seems more believable to me as a guy who's in charge of things.

Now, comparing the characters:
Both have traits that I like and dislike.
Mac is definitely more useful. I sometimes wonder why Jack is even part of SG-1, as he rarely does anything. Anytime they're in a tough situation, it seems he has to ask his teammates what to do, and the only thing he contributes to the mission is some sarcasm. Having said that, I do like his cynical/sarcastic attitude. Mac was a little TOO much of a goody-two-shoes. I know they made him that way to be a good role model for the children watching the show, but as an adult, I sometimes find his squeaky-clean persona to be a bit annoying and unrealistic.



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 20 October 2011 - 02:22 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



Miasma, about the third time I read a post withoout looking at the poster and thought to myself, what a cracking post, in all three cases it was Miasma's. Or perhaps I just agree with you, people tend to confuse making an excellent argument to people whom you simply agree with

in the battle of the baldies, Im afraid i have to agree with you, Davis acting is quite superior to Elcar's.

Definitely at present time while I still give Mac a watch or two from time to time, SG-1 is a series I prefer. I dont get the preachy tone, the infantile writing and the caricatures villains. Im afraid, while Ill always have wonderful memories about MAc, its character, the good times I spent watching the series in my youth, and many other good things, as a series Im not in love anymore



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 21 October 2011 - 05:11 AM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



QUOTE

Miasma, about the third time I read a post withoout looking at the poster and thought to myself, what a cracking post, in all three cases it was Miasma's.


Wow, thanks... I fully expected to get flamed for it! (especially the part about Dana Elcar.)




 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 21 October 2011 - 12:29 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



I like controversial opinions, as long as there arent simply for trolling.

I should clarify that although not "in love" with the series anymore, I still watch it and enjoy many episodes. but now Ive developed a bit of a critical sense about it that I never had before. Its probably because of getting old...



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Miasma
Posted: 22 October 2011 - 06:15 AM                                    
Quote Post


Phoenix Operative
******

Posts: 1,045
Joined: 9 Oct 2008
Gender:  
Country:
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: 
Episode:
Vehicle:
Jacket:  
House:  



QUOTE (Dr Zito @ 21 October 2011 - 12:32 PM)
I should clarify that although not "in love" with the series anymore, I still watch it and enjoy many episodes. but now Ive developed a bit of a critical sense about it that I never had before. Its probably because of getting old...

That's exactly how I feel about the show. I can still enjoy it from time to time, and there are episodes that I still think are well done, but I now see its faults a lot more clearly than I did as a kid. I think kids aren't as discriminating (or at least they weren't in the 80s... can't speak for kids today.) Back then, I honestly didn't notice how bad the acting was, for example. I remember watching the show with my mother, and she would be cracking up over the cheesy dialogue/acting, and I just didn't get what was so bad about it. Now, of course, it's very obvious. But I guess that's one of the perks of being a kid.

And in spite of its flaws, I do think it's a shame that they don't make kids shows like this anymore. My parents always felt safe plopping me down in front of MacGyver because they knew he was a nice guy who never did anything wrong, didn't drink, didn't smoke, and ate all his vegetables. I don't think they would have felt as comfortable plopping me down in front of, say, "24". I'm not really sure what action heroes are out there for kids in today's world.




 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 22 October 2011 - 07:36 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



mac's greatest asset for a parent was his love for science. I used to discuss the science angle with muy granpa a lot. Its was great for him to see that I watched a series that tried to teach to love something a bit alien to kids, like chemistry, physics or maths. That was probably my favourite aspect, and that unlike other series, you never got awkward moments like sex scenes or grown ups talk. Now of course those are things I look for in a series (not exclusively but there are part of the world and life)

Mac was a superb role model for kids, the best you could ever ask for. I think tv has become far more complex and demanding nowadays, audiences simply would laugh at someone like mac in todays world. Kids' heroes today are serial killers like dexter or womanisers. Complex, hard to box in, characters. I think we lived in a st claus time while todays kids are part of more scientific and realistic world where human values take the back seat to technology, success and aggression.

The world has evolved in many positive ways, IMO, but one of the aspects that actually have gone backwards are the enjoyment of childhood for kids. Society, media start putting into their brains far too early things from the adult world, like money, sex, success. They dont have the untroubled childhood some of us had, and of which series like MacGyver were an integral part. I also used to love watching a double session with seaquest too. Seaquest was actually a pretty bad series, but like Mac, part of that "safe childhood" I had. Nowadays I couldnt watch it, rather see something like the Wire.



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Bushwalker
  Posted: 22 October 2011 - 10:07 PM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 19 Oct 2011
Gender:  Male
Country: Australia
SAK owned: Trekker

Favorites
Season: season 6
Episode:
Vehicle: Motorcycle
Jacket:  Brown bomber
House:  Second Loft



QUOTE (Dr Zito @ 22 October 2011 - 06:39 PM)
.........................................................................
Mac was a superb role model for kids, the best you could ever ask for. I think tv has become far more complex and demanding nowadays, audiences simply would laugh at someone like mac in todays world. Kids' heroes today are serial killers like dexter or womanisers.
......................................................................... 

ohmy.gif Shows like "Dexter" are definitely NOT suitable for children ~ and I would be quite suspicious of any parents allowing (younger) children to watch such violent and amoral series...

And as for role models or heroes ~ any kids making a role model out of Dexter would be a prime candidate for psychiatric help..



 
PM                                                                     
Top
Dr Zito
Posted: 23 October 2011 - 10:55 AM                                    
Quote Post


Special Forces Agent
***

Posts: 127
Joined: 12 Apr 2010
Gender:  Male
Country: Colombia
SAK owned:

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:MacGyver 5x01
Vehicle: Jeep
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



its obviously not something normal parents would actively pursue, but kids watch series like dexter, and think he's a very cool character. Perhaps its not the bext example.

what I meant was that today's role models have to be three dimensional, someone like mac dont think would "fly" for todays skeptical kids



 
PMEmail Poster                                                                     
Top
Robert
Posted: 10 December 2011 - 09:01 PM                                    
Quote Post


Challengers Volunteer
*

Posts: 11
Joined: 10 Dec 2011
Gender:  Male
Country: Afghanistan
SAK owned: N/A

Favorites
Season: season 3
Episode:
Vehicle: Truck
Jacket:  Black/Navy flight
House:  House boat



I like both equally, I tend to identify with Jack O'Neill due to my own background but both are good.

I'll watch Dexter too but NOT with my kids. ha ha



 
PM                                                                     
Top
0 User(s) are reading this topic (0 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
 0 Members:
     

 Topic Options Reply to this topic Fast Reply Start new topicStart Poll