I think it's all bare wood that makes the MacGyver feel. Kind of log cabin/boyscout-ish feel. Interestinly they did that with both the second season loft and houseboat, so it was obviously something they were consciously doing.
That second interior is probably a bit crowded for my personal taste. I prefer some open living space.
The first one certainly gives a Houseboat feel with the french doors at the end of the room.
And the wooden steps - straight out of the second season loft.